Dr DT's team...

Started by stew42, March 06, 2013, 05:37:37 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

stew42



Backs: Way underdone. Would think that 3 premos are necessary. He needs to hope to God that his rookies play and don't get vested. Gibbs should be in there. 7/10

Mids: Not awful. But having Gibbs at M6 is stupid. Put him in the backs. Same with Bartel. Having DPP in your mids means you are insecure of the JS of your fwds and backs. Strong, but poorly structured. 8/10

Rucks: Probably again too strong here. Cox is good. Kreuz is a risky choice, if he stays fit, I reckon he'll go 90. Leuy at R3 is riduculous overkill. He is not like Zmith or Giles of the past, he cost more than double them! 8.5/10

Fwds: Franklin won't hold his 2012 average. Chances are he won't score 13 goals in a game this year. If you take out his 200, he averaged... 94 in 2012. That's less than Pav. His next highest score was 130 in Rnd 1. In 2011, his highest score was 144. In 2012, he had 6 scores below 80, and one 81 (in 2012) So what I'm saying is, if you do pick Buddy, don't expect any 150+, or even 130+, scores in 2013. He isn't God (end Buddy rant). Robbo is good, should improve on an already sterling DT game. Despite people going off him on FF, LeCras is underpriced. Petterd is still on the rookie list, isn't he? Not sure of his likelihood for games. Varcoe is a good midpricer. His rookies are expensive! Patton will be a rollercoaster... This line has 2 premos, one underpriced premo, and 2 midpricers. I'd want to see more premos in there. 7.5/10

Overall: Most of the teams I've seen on FF are better than this. Structurally this team is appalling, with overpowered mids and rucks, and underdone backs and fwds.  7.75/10  (Note: my pass mark is an 8)

Jukes

All I needed to know he was a spud was his top two midfielders (note: applies to all players).

tbagrocks

Lol any more proof that Cotchin is a spud?

Jroo

If he puts Gibbs down back and Barttel up forward his team would look better. I like his selection of Ricky Petterd  8)

Aaron8

wow this makes me feel so much better about my team

Toga

#5
Could've been worse... Could've picked Dangerfield over Cotchin ::)

Jroo

He posted his new team on Twitter not long ago

A lot better than his last

Toga

Quote from: JROO8 on March 06, 2013, 06:03:42 PM
If he puts Gibbs down back and Barttel up forward his team would look better. I like his selection of Ricky Petterd  8)

I actually don't mind Petterd in there either Jroo - reckon he would be a great smokey POD once he gets upgraded to the senior list 8)

Jroo

Quote from: Toga on March 06, 2013, 06:09:28 PM
Quote from: JROO8 on March 06, 2013, 06:03:42 PM
If he puts Gibbs down back and Barttel up forward his team would look better. I like his selection of Ricky Petterd  8)

I actually don't mind Petterd in there either Jroo - reckon he would be a great smokey POD once he gets upgraded to the senior list 8)
Yeah I'm considering himself, out of him or Knights. But I'd love to have both, but then I'd have too many Tigers  :-\

tbagrocks

Too many Richmond players, the one i'd change first would be Cotchin>anyone

SydneyRox

#10
Quote from: Jukes on March 06, 2013, 05:46:38 PM
All I needed to know he was a spud was his top two midfielders (note: applies to all players).

You need a new line....

Nice analysis Stew. Pretty spot on. I am going to find the article he wrote, would be some humour there you would expect to justify some of the calls...

Cant find this team anywhere Stew... where did you get it from??? Are you Dr DT??   ???

Toga

He posted it on Facebook SR, I tried finding it on AFL.com but couldn't find it either! :o

SydneyRox

Facebook friends with Dr DT..... hmmmmmmm  :o


Windigo

Pretty decent team. No Pendles.  :-\

Toga

Quote from: SydneyRox on March 06, 2013, 08:03:14 PM
Facebook friends with Dr DT..... hmmmmmmm  :o

Haha oops worded that poorly ::)

AFL's Facebook page posted it!