JPK vs Cotch

[chadsta112]

Can't split these blokes. Richmond will improve which means Cotch's scores will in theory. JPK is a proven gun. Help.

[jfitty]

I'm really liking JPK this season. Sydney have a great start to the year draw wise, and he would be fractionally more unique than Cotchin too. He gets my vote and will easily average 120+ this season

[kilbluff1985]

I'm really liking JPK this season. Sydney have a great start to the year draw wise, and he would be fractionally more unique than Cotchin too. He gets my vote and will easily average 120+ this season

Yeah JPK plays GWS & GC in first 2 rounds I'd get him

[gossiboy]

In before tbag and quinny go at it again.

Already been asked, just ignore the Danger comments.

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,71272.0.html

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,72505.msg997292.html#msg997292

[tbagrocks]

Yeah ignore the Danger comments because everyone already knows he is better

[TheAnt]

Hasn't this been done to death already?

[Ricochet]

Hasn't this been done to death already?

Yep. Really need to use the search function fellas.
JPK for me tho

[Justin Bieber]

Really JPK over Cotchin? Really?

[quinny88]

In before tbag and quinny go at it again.

Already been asked, just ignore the Danger comments.

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,71272.0.html

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,72505.msg997292.html#msg997292

Contrary to what you may think I'm not actually a one eyed Richmond supporter. I only have 2 Richmond players in my team.
I would take JPK over cotchin due to Sydney's soft start to the season. I have both if them anyway though.

People thinking that JPK will be unique.. Don't be so sure. He seems pretty bloody popular amongst the people on this page

[tbagrocks]

Really JPK over Cotchin? Really?

Really! Haven't you heard? ???  Cotchin sucks!

I'll have Joch before Trent anyday, at least untill Trent proves consistant

[Justin Bieber]

Really JPK over Cotchin? Really?

Really! Haven't you heard? ???  Cotchin sucks!

I'll have Joch before Trent anyday, at least untill Trent proves consistant

You say Danger is better and needs to show consistency. Why didn't take spud field 4 years to actually score some decent numbers?

[Griffo1982]

Really JPK over Cotchin? Really?

Really! Haven't you heard? ???  Cotchin sucks!

I'll have Joch before Trent anyday, at least untill Trent proves consistant

You say Danger is better and needs to show consistency. Why didn't take spud field 4 years to actually score some decent numbers?

Didn't it take 4 years for him to finally get a full time gig in the midfield?

[mark621]

this will be the battle of the next perma captain
id take cotchin as a roughy to win it as well

sydney are great at sharing points and always have been

cotchin has a decent side around him and he has the talent to punch out consistant 130's to 140's with the odd 160-170 slapped in their

[tbagrocks]

this will be the battle of the next perma captain
id take cotchin as a roughy to win it as well

sydney are great at sharing points and always have been

cotchin has a decent side around him and he has the talent to punch out consistant 130's to 140's with the odd 160-170 slapped in their

cough *bullshower* cough

[tbagrocks]

Really JPK over Cotchin? Really?

Really! Haven't you heard? ???  Cotchin sucks!

I'll have Joch before Trent anyday, at least untill Trent proves consistant

You say Danger is better and needs to show consistency. Why didn't take spud field 4 years to actually score some decent numbers?

Didn't it take 4 years for him to finally get a full time gig in the midfield?

Ha I missed this, yes it did, Craig saw him as a need in the forwardline