Please rate my team and offer any help...never done one before

croweyrocks · March 05, 2013, 04:22:16 PM

The_Fitz · March 05, 2013, 04:44:33 PM

a lot of Collingwood players there, just remember the byes later in the year, some good good choices there tho.
I like Luke Ball and I like Cox in the ruck. Some good rookies there

Ringo · March 05, 2013, 04:50:13 PM

Not a bad effort for someone who has never done SC before.

Def: Think you have spent a bit much here. Scotland is missing the first 2 games due to suspension so you may want to reconsider. Jacobs is a bit expensive to have as 5th defender when you make $170k by going Luke Brown or similar.
Mids: Not in favour of all 3 pies together as you may have problems in bye Round 13, Beams a reasonable POD though. Reddan is possibly going to be effected by Moloneys arrival at lions but go with gut feeling on this one. 5 prems plus Ball sound.
Rucks: Would prefer Cox in forward line so you can take advantage of Rowes DPP.
Fwds: Very weak here Replace deBoer with Cox and then look at what ruck you can afford. Other suggestion is to use Money saved manipulating defence to get another prem forward,

Watch Rookies who will actually play. eg Daw is injured and may miss a couple of games.

Nice start but needs a bit of tweaking Rate 7/10 due to forwards being very weak.

kilbluff1985 · March 05, 2013, 05:07:29 PM

Due to lack of forward rookie options I think it should be your strongest line not your weakest which it is

croweyrocks · March 05, 2013, 11:54:40 PM

Thanks for the help

nightwalker_1310au · March 06, 2013, 08:14:00 AM

Yeah hey maw too many pie players. Sound like a pie supporter like me. Would consider downgrading some players and upgrading forward line. Other then that ok for first timer. Gotta start somewhere.

croweyrocks · March 07, 2013, 12:10:31 PM

Not a pies supporter but trying to find the best fits. thanks for the help

Mat0369 · March 07, 2013, 12:34:24 PM

It was said before but way to many pies in the mids. Look at downgrading Scotty to free up cash and upgrade one of Swan Pendles or Beams to Ablett. I would probably get rid of Swan out of those guys and look to upgrade to him later in the year.

If you are starting Cox in the ruck, try and get Rowe into your forwards so you have the DPP link. Maybe look at getting rid of Krakouer as well. Also monitor Balls progress before round 1. He needs to play a game to be worth picking up.