Rate My Team With Photo (Be Critical)

Started by Bruce500, March 04, 2013, 11:40:24 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Bruce500

Hi Guys,

Please see attached photo, all feedback is welcome

Defenders
Goddard - Grimes - Gibbs - Vlastuin - Pittard - Colquhoun (Docherty - Terlich)

Midfielders
Swan - Pendlebury - Selwood S - Dangerfield - Murphy -  Mitchell K - O'Meara - Viney (Crouch - Blicavs)

Rucks
Cox - Leuenberger (Rowe - Currie)

Forwards
Bartel - Zorko - Rockliff - Robinson - LeCras - Varcoe (Macaffer - Lee)



Comment away.....Cheers

Shanus_

I'm guessing you left O'Meara out?

Otherwise looks good, similar to mine, just different rookies, I like the looks of Stevenson, Wines and Neade from Port.. Also good Dangers as a POD hopefully too..

8/10..

Bruce500


lolamusi


Bruce500


RookieDTer

Quote from: Bruce500 on March 05, 2013, 07:28:04 PM
Quote from: lolamusi on March 05, 2013, 07:24:44 PM
honestly too many ruck defenders.

Please clarify a little better please
One too many rookie defenders.

-Colq, +Hartlett, for example, would be nice.

Though, you don't post what cash you have left, so hard to recommend any trades!

Personally, I think Scott Selwood has better value than Joel Selwood..... so, could save $30k.

Could go -Le Cras, - J.Selwood -Colq +Byrnes, +S.Selwood +Harltett if you had the cash?

Oh, and, instantly, stop what you are doing and do -Blicvas +O'Meara.

I can't see Dwyer playing, would like to see Lee in there instead.

COuld even do - Le Cras + Lee, move Macaffer to F6 - which would free up load of cash.

Bruce500

thanks mate have $4300 cash left.

dwyer was put it as i was unsure which player at that value would play...thanks for the advice

dont you think o'meara & blicvas are worthy of a spot
Quote from: RookieDTer on March 05, 2013, 09:42:49 PM
Quote from: Bruce500 on March 05, 2013, 07:28:04 PM
Quote from: lolamusi on March 05, 2013, 07:24:44 PM
honestly too many ruck defenders.

Please clarify a little better please
One too many rookie defenders.

-Colq, +Hartlett, for example, would be nice.

Though, you don't post what cash you have left, so hard to recommend any trades!

Personally, I think Scott Selwood has better value than Joel Selwood..... so, could save $30k.

Could go -Le Cras, - J.Selwood -Colq +Byrnes, +S.Selwood +Harltett if you had the cash?

Oh, and, instantly, stop what you are doing and do -Blicvas +O'Meara.

I can't see Dwyer playing, would like to see Lee in there instead.

COuld even do - Le Cras + Lee, move Macaffer to F6 - which would free up load of cash.

RookieDTer

Quote from: Bruce500 on March 05, 2013, 10:18:34 PM
thanks mate have $4300 cash left.

dwyer was put it as i was unsure which player at that value would play...thanks for the advice

dont you think o'meara & blicvas are worthy of a spot?
Did you have O'Meara when you first posted the team? I couldn't find him.

O'Meara is definitely worthy a spot.

Blicvas might be alright, but, not at the expense of O'Meara.

Also consider Kerridge in that final Rookie spot, if he gets named. Having a decent preseason, has a body and is DPP.