West Coast Vs Collingwood discussion

[Phasir]

nice seeing that Scooter is tagging the crap out of Dane, bodes well for those (like me) who won't pick him :)

the less people that pick him the better, smashing the DT score out even with his crap goal efficiency & 5 frees against.. highest score in the match so far and that's when he's playing an accountable game, just wait until Sharrod's back so he can be an offensive beast ;)
*he's also playing on Pendles for now :P

[Noz]

Rosa has gone down with a hamstring.

[Phasir]

Rosa has gone down with a hamstring.

they took him off just as a precaution though didn't they?

[Mr.Craig]

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,70002.0.html

[Phasir]

& Scooter finishes with 119 in a shortened version of the game while tagging 8) nice stuff

[Andrew]

I don't even like Cloke anymore, just seems completely disinterested

Not his fault that every contest he goes to he is getting double teamed

When will that not happen? He's far too big a risk...

& Scooter finishes with 119 in a shortened version of the game while tagging 8) nice stuff

Selwood's first 4 games: Freo, Hawks, Melbourne, and Carlton. I only like one of those opponents for him unfortunately, I can see him tagging and being in a tough midfield slog in the other 3. Regular tagging as he does makes him DT inconsistent.

[Phasir]

I don't even like Cloke anymore, just seems completely disinterested

Not his fault that every contest he goes to he is getting double teamed

When will that not happen? He's far too big a risk...

& Scooter finishes with 119 in a shortened version of the game while tagging 8) nice stuff

Selwood's first 4 games: Freo, Hawks, Melbourne, and Carlton. I only like one of those opponents for him unfortunately, I can see him tagging and being in a tough midfield slog in the other 3. Regular tagging as he does makes him DT inconsistent.

because Collingwood have a crap midfield ::)  he's not a regular tagger any more anyway

[Mr.Craig]

I don't even like Cloke anymore, just seems completely disinterested

Not his fault that every contest he goes to he is getting double teamed

When will that not happen? He's far too big a risk...

& Scooter finishes with 119 in a shortened version of the game while tagging 8) nice stuff

Selwood's first 4 games: Freo, Hawks, Melbourne, and Carlton. I only like one of those opponents for him unfortunately, I can see him tagging and being in a tough midfield slog in the other 3. Regular tagging as he does makes him DT inconsistent.

He actually averaged 101.5 vs those teams last year but your point still stands about the risk of inconsistency.

[Jukes]

There goes Clokey from my side :(

He'll probs smash next two weeks and get back in though, hopefully.

[Andrew]

because Collingwood have a crap midfield ::)  he's not a regular tagger any more anyway

Collingwood did have an understrength midfield today - Beams and Ball still to return. And yes Wellingham may be the number 1 tagger now but he's in a battle to be fit for Round 1.

He actually averaged 101.5 vs those teams last year but your point still stands about the risk of inconsistency.

Yep, I looked up his 2012 stats before I made the point. He played 2 games v Freo & Hawks each. In 1 game against those teams, he scored 71 and 82 before doing better in the 2nd game. Doesn't fill me with confidence, but it's a shame we aren't seeing him play with Wellingham to get a better idea on what role each will play.

[tbagrocks]

Why the flower would the woods name the great Benny Kennedy but not play him :o >:(

flower Collingwood maybe leave him for a team that wil play him ::)

[Colliwobblers]

you won't see much of kennedy this season and why would you, players that would be a lock in most teams best 22 will warm the pine for the Piesthis season.

but you will see him when krak and caff and didak are all gone and he will be a gun and he will play 200 games for the Pies and will be a premiership player :)

Shaw looked solid for SC D3 did he not.

Russell failed to solidify his spot in my side, not for what he did or didn't do, but for what Clarke DID do... got plenty of it.

Witts as expected is miles ahead of grundy but I still doubt he will play enough to warrant picking in fantasy.

Lynch was not much help to cloke he needs to be for cloke to be fantasy relevant which he needs to be for the Pies to be FLAG relevant,

who isn't starting Swan?

well probably should have a look at the history of Swans nab cup output and rethink that . :)

[tbagrocks]

Russell is stupid but Benny won't make the same mistake, first oppertunity and he's back to South Australia, why stay at a team that bearly needs to play you :o

[Colliwobblers]

Russell is stupid but Benny won't make the same mistake, first oppertunity and he's back to South Australia, why stay at a team that bearly needs to play you :o

Premierships :)

[elephants]

Russell is stupid but Benny won't make the same mistake, first oppertunity and he's back to South Australia, why stay at a team that bearly needs to play you :o

Premierships :)

Do you get a medal if you dont play a game?

It doesn't matter anyway. The cup is heading West and it ain't to the Purple side of Perth.