Fyfe VS Mundy

[lowry]

Is Fyfe fit enough or Mundy too old?

[nrich102]

I swear this thread has been made like 100 times this preseason. But Fyfe over Mundy

[lowry]

I swear this thread has been made like 100 times this preseason. But Fyfe over Mundy

Yes I know but I want to know if there is any changes in thoughts after the Freo Adelaide practice match

[GCSkiwi]

Currently have Fyfe but my word he struggled with the Carrots tag. I'd like to see him again as Carrots can get the best of anyone, but from today Mundy looks the better of the two...

[quinny88]

Currently have Fyfe but my word he struggled with the Carrots tag. I'd like to see him again as Carrots can get the best of anyone, but from today Mundy looks the better of the two...

Surely they didnt tag in a nab cup game? lol

[ubeaut]

Tagged and struggled. Will be watching Fyfe closely after that.

[Jroo]

It's a close call, think they will both be good options, but if I was only picking one I'd go with Nat Fyfe.
I think Fyfe has a lot of potential to be a star and I reckon he'll average more than Mundy just.

[Colliwobblers]

yeah carrots is not quite raines or lrt or crowley but he does a great job all the same,

Barlow will attract a tag often which may help Fyfe but he is still young and like murphy will struggle for awhile when he gets worn like a glove,

Hill gets tagged more than any of them anyway so Fyfe should be tagged a lot less with Hill and Barlow in the lineup...

[Hagebear]

yeah carrots is not quite raines or lrt or crowley but he does a great job all the same,

Barlow will attract a tag often which may help Fyfe but he is still young and like murphy will struggle for awhile when he gets worn like a glove,

Hill gets tagged more than any of them anyway so Fyfe should be tagged a lot less with Hill and Barlow in the lineup...

Well Mundy will never get a tag and looked really good in a team that got flogged tonight.

[blue]

yeah carrots is not quite raines or lrt or crowley but he does a great job all the same,

Barlow will attract a tag often which may help Fyfe but he is still young and like murphy will struggle for awhile when he gets worn like a glove,

Hill gets tagged more than any of them anyway so Fyfe should be tagged a lot less with Hill and Barlow in the lineup...

is hill really that good?

[batt]

yeah carrots is not quite raines or lrt or crowley but he does a great job all the same,

Barlow will attract a tag often which may help Fyfe but he is still young and like murphy will struggle for awhile when he gets worn like a glove,

Hill gets tagged more than any of them anyway so Fyfe should be tagged a lot less with Hill and Barlow in the lineup...

is hill really that good?

He's explosive and game changing.  He can have 15 touches and impact a game more than someone who has 35.

Annoyed that the wheels are falling off the Fyfe train and I wish it could have been discovered later.  There is no chance he can average 115+ when he gets tagged and it's pretty obvious he's high up the pecking order.

[Jroo]

yeah carrots is not quite raines or lrt or crowley but he does a great job all the same,

Barlow will attract a tag often which may help Fyfe but he is still young and like murphy will struggle for awhile when he gets worn like a glove,

Hill gets tagged more than any of them anyway so Fyfe should be tagged a lot less with Hill and Barlow in the lineup...

is hill really that good?

He's explosive and game changing.  He can have 15 touches and impact a game more than someone who has 35.

Annoyed that the wheels are falling off the Fyfe train and I wish it could have been discovered later.  There is no chance he can average 115+ when he gets tagged and it's pretty obvious he's high up the pecking order.

Yep exactly batt, Hill can have a massive impact on a game.
Fyfe would probably be the first player the opposition go to, to tag won't he? I'm thinking about just paying the extra cash and going with Jelwood

[lowry]

Fyfe had been leading the poll the whole time before yesterday's match, now mundy is ahead

[Keeper27]

Fyfe had been leading the poll the whole time before yesterday's match, now mundy is ahead

mundy was on most peoples teams before he got injured.
now that he's back and firing i can see him getting 105+

[tbagrocks]

Surely us Fyfe backers aren't going off because of a pre-season game played marsh the 2nd ???

Have I any real reason to be worried? ???