please rate my team (pic)

[jackel82]

Please rate my team I have 100k left open to suggestion.
thanks

[Keeper27]

nice team, good structure.

4 super premo's is a great starting point. nice choices.

hibberd is a nice POD. newman will avg more then him and he's only $17K more.
Yaz/atley could avg around the same too and they're cheaper options.

bellchambers is unproven but can shine as the Dons main ruckman.


solid team with good players.
good luck.



check out my team
http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,72754.msg1004857.html#msg1004857

[jackel82]

thanks keeper27

I might keep hibberd for now been swapping him in and out a lot but i think he is set to get some time in the midfield this year. Has been very good so far in the NAB cup.

Good point on Tbell not proven yet so he is a risk, his form has been very good in the Nab cup as well, he looks very fit this year and has the ability to go forward.  I also like Ryder, he was good last until he got injured, then terrible. he is a real confidence player, when he is confident he is a fantastic player, but when he is not he can be shocking. Im hoping Tbell can become a consistant performer this year. But at he same time Im sure someone like Jacobs would be a very consistent performer, is proven and less of a risk. So many derisions. lol

[tor01doc]

I like it.

Your defense will cost you either trades or points in round 13. 4 sharing the bye already.

Need one of the 3 hot Pies to start I reckon. I wonder whether Moloney is overpriced.

My lunatic Essendon mate reckons Bellchambers is primed for a breakout year and will kick more goals than before.

Rowe and Currie I like more than your R3 andR4. Esp DPP to Cox.

Like your forwards except no Buddy. Lewis to captain us a bit more this year with hodge in knee pain trouble already.

Good work.

[jackel82]

thanks tor01doc

point taken about the byes, I have not even looked at the effects of them. which I should
Hmm cant bring myself to have a prem pie mid, Id rather loose then have any one of those three, lol
I do like ball though thinking he might be better value then Moloney, hmm not sure on that one, would really like to see Ball play in the NAB cup.


Im hoping Tbell does well this year, looked great in the NAB cup very good hands for so early in the season, we will see I guess
I had no idea on the r3 and r4 have changed them as per your advice.
walker could very well become buddy by the time the season starts, depending on where that 99k needs to go.

cheers

[johnnytheboy1]

Def: I think your better off with Atley or Yarran than Hibberd they will average  pretty much the same. Not Sure about pittard either Stevenson may be the better option.
Mids: Can't fault. Moloney is becoming a popular pick.
Rucks: : Bellchambers may be good POD
FWDS: Good POD in Lewis can score highly

Overall you have good team with some nice unique picks which you need to seperate yourself from the rest.  8/10

[jackel82]

Thanks Johny the boy. Really making me think about Atley or newman now, Newman will be on the wing a lot it seems. noted for stevenson will change him, I really dont know much about pittard just looked ok in the nab so far.

[Caldera31]

Turn Hibberd into Hartlett.

Great side, loving Tom Bellchambers in your ruck.

With the upgrade to Hartlett I'd give your side 9/10

[jackel82]

Ok so I have made a few changes, do you think this one is better?

[jackel82]

anyone like the new side better? I have got buddy, Fyfe, and atley in now, and changed the rokies around a bit. Forward line is stronger now, and so is midefield I guess, but the backline bay me a bit week

[Crouchy182]

anyone like the new side better? I have got buddy, Fyfe, and atley in now, and changed the rokies around a bit. Forward line is stronger now, and so is midefield I guess, but the backline bay me a bit week

Really, really like this team. That being said its dangerously close to mine now so i might be a bit biased.