Why do I keep playing with my team?!?

[kma07]

Latest team at the bottom *sigh*




Hi guys, please rate my team.

Any comments, advice, critiques welcomed!

Cheers

[Jackross10]

Great team overall ! Not to sure on martin maybe look at Christensen and then look at going mundy to Fyfe

[Sabretooth Tigers]

Very nice first draft 007
You didn't mention available salary cap ? I'd consider swapping Jake Neade for Sam Kerridge, not sure Kerridge will get a lot of game time. But rookies are all subject to preseason form and round 1 selection. Sam Wright went very well in the first round of the NAB and you could possibly consider him over Atley if you have a spare 14k plus. Apart from that all is good and wish you the very best of luck.

[Ringo]

Very nice 1st up draft.

Rookies will sort themselves out over the next couple of weeks so just watch performances in full games to get a sound idea of who to pick,

Def: Solid without being spectacular. Use NAB Cup to see how Suns are using Broughton prior to selecting.  He seemed a bit all over the place in the mini games.  Think Atley may break out this year so sound selection.
Mids: Very Strong here and nice choice with Mundy - Just ensure he plays in Round 1. Think he presents same value as Fyfe but cheaper. Goodes may be a waste in mids though you may have better rookie options available.
Rucks: Solid
Fwds: Sound - not a fan Bartell this year basically because mid time may be reduced but watch during NAB cup and the fact his SC scores have declined each tear for the past 3 years.  You need you Forwards averaging more than 100 and Bartell averaged only 98.5 last year, Martin will be up and down as we know.

Just watch your trading as atm you have 6 of your prem keepers with the Round 13 bye

Very sound base to work with Rate Team 8.5/10

[kma07]

Great team overall ! Not to sure on martin maybe look at Christensen and then look at going mundy to Fyfe

Thanks, I know Martin burnt everyone who had him last year, but I think I'll give him one more year  :-\

I originally had Fyfe in there but decided Mundy is cheaper and can produce the same and is a bit of a POD.

[kma07]

Very nice first draft 007
You didn't mention available salary cap ? I'd consider swapping Jake Neade for Sam Kerridge, not sure Kerridge will get a lot of game time. But rookies are all subject to preseason form and round 1 selection. Sam Wright went very well in the first round of the NAB and you could possibly consider him over Atley if you have a spare 14k plus. Apart from that all is good and wish you the very best of luck.

I have $114k remaining.  I'll keep an eye on Neade thanks!
Hopefully will have a better idea of the rookies after NAB.

Thanks and good luck also  ;D

[kma07]

Very nice 1st up draft.

Rookies will sort themselves out over the next couple of weeks so just watch performances in full games to get a sound idea of who to pick,

Def: Solid without being spectacular. Use NAB Cup to see how Suns are using Broughton prior to selecting.  He seemed a bit all over the place in the mini games.  Think Atley may break out this year so sound selection.
Mids: Very Strong here and nice choice with Mundy - Just ensure he plays in Round 1. Think he presents same value as Fyfe but cheaper. Goodes may be a waste in mids though you may have better rookie options available.
Rucks: Solid
Fwds: Sound - not a fan Bartell this year basically because mid time may be reduced but watch during NAB cup and the fact his SC scores have declined each tear for the past 3 years.  You need you Forwards averaging more than 100 and Bartell averaged only 98.5 last year, Martin will be up and down as we know.

Just watch your trading as atm you have 6 of your prem keepers with the Round 13 bye

Very sound base to work with Rate Team 8.5/10

Thanks Ringo, always appreciate your feedback.  I think I might put Stevie J back in for Bartell and have him on the pine for round 1. 

[kma07]

What are people's thoughts on:

Byrnes -> Krakouer
Bartell -> Tex

[Ringo]

Solid changes proposed but just continue to watch Krak in the NAB cup - Maybe fighting for a spot with Didak. Also watch Pettard and Varcoe as they may be alternate options to byrnes if worried.

[tor01doc]

I wonder if Krak will be a super sub?

Walker on the rise / Bartel in the twilight of his career - I like Tex at this stage.

Nice team with a few well thought out risks like Broughton, Atley and Martin.

Rucks are a possible weakness.

[johnnytheboy1]

I agree on the Bartel to walker not so sure about byrnes to Krakouer i think Varcoe is the better option.
Anyway this is how i rate your team
Def: Don't really like Broughton might be better off with Heppell or Jack Watts but like the Pick of Atley.
Mids: Mundy is a Good POD as long as he stays fit.Goodes looked good last night.
Rucks: Standard
Fwds: Replace Bartel & Byrnes and you should be right.

Overall a good balanced team give it an 8/10

[Keeper27]

hmm... the structure is fine but some players concern me.

broughton @ D3 is worrying... TBH he'd be lucky to sit in my D4. better options mate, look elsewhere.

before mundy's slight injury he was set in everybodies team, and now that he's back he will be an amazing POD, just make sure he is 100% should pump out 105+

rucks are standard, not sold on goldy.

fwd's are fine.

just a few thoughts.
move goodes down back, use the money to U/G your R1 & D3.



check out my team.
http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,72754.msg1004857.html#msg1004857

[kma07]

What are peoples thoughts ?
Still not the finished article..

Haven't decided on Luey to ?

$9700 remaining

[nightwalker_1310au]

Yeah still some work in progress at leat your honest. Leuy is out for couple rounds as I heard cause I had to re shuffle my team to get better ruck. Midfield too solid would recommend going three to four premos Mids and throw in a break out player. Forward line is all ruck players. I would consider players fr Mids to get. Other then that cause work in progress and can see nice uniques in team mate. All the best rate team solid 6/10. Can u rate my team please.
http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,74063.0.html

[kma07]

Please break it down..