Sylvia vs Sipposs vs watts ??

[dubizzy]

Which one and why ? Looking at getting one of these 3

[Adamant]

Sylvia by a very long way. He is a proven 90s average player, whose 2012 average was purely ruined from his spine injury he sustained in the NAB Cup.

Watts and Siposs are both unproven, although I think Watts could be a possible 85 average, but still a big risk.

Sylvia >>> Watts > Siposs IMO.

[Windigo]

Sylvia, and its not even close.

[The F.A.R.K.]

Siposs

I worry about sylvia, melbourne have brought in a lot of mids/fwds this year who are all in their best 22. While sylvia is in the best 22 all it takes is a slight role change and we now have a 65av dud

Rodan, Toumpas, Viney, Dawes, Byrnes, Terlich, Jones, Gilles all in best 22

[chaosAD]

They are all camels, if u need one of these you are in massive trouble

[Ricochet]

Sylvia by a very long way. He is a proven 90s average player, whose 2012 average was purely ruined from his spine injury he sustained in the NAB Cup.

Watts and Siposs are both unproven, although I think Watts could be a possible 85 average, but still a big risk.

Sylvia >>> Watts > Siposs IMO.

Yep this. Well said Adamant

[strikes91]

am I missing something.... why is sipposs all of a sudden popular ?

[tbagrocks]

am I missing something.... why is sipposs all of a sudden popular ?

There are people who think he's getting Goddards role

Unfortianetly he's not getting Goddards No 1 draft pick talent

[blackrose]

Siposs

I worry about sylvia, melbourne have brought in a lot of mids/fwds this year who are all in their best 22. While sylvia is in the best 22 all it takes is a slight role change and we now have a 65av dud

Rodan, Toumpas, Viney, Dawes, Byrnes, Terlich, Jones, Gilles all in best 22

I would say Sylvia is in Melbourne's top 3 players, possibly number one , let alone struggling to make Melbourne's best 22. He had a pretty impressive 2nd half of the year in 2012 once he got over his injury niggles and regained fitness.

[Adamant]

am I missing something.... why is sipposs all of a sudden popular ?

There are people who think he's getting Goddards role

Unfortianetly he's not getting Goddards No 1 draft pick talent

Haha nice. ;D

[Windigo]

am I missing something.... why is sipposs all of a sudden popular ?

There are people who think he's getting Goddards role

Unfortianetly he's not getting Goddards No 1 draft pick talent

Haha nice. ;D

Classic.  8)

[azza707]

am I missing something.... why is sipposs all of a sudden popular ?

There are people who think he's getting Goddards role

Unfortianetly he's not getting Goddards No 1 draft pick talent

Haha nice. ;D

Classic.  8)

True, but also very harsh. Watch out for this kid cos he is going to be a quality player and has a good leg on him. Will go into the Goddard role and while he may not play with Goddard ability, he's in a prime position on the park to rack up the numbers, thats why hes so popular.

[Hagebear]

am I missing something.... why is sipposs all of a sudden popular ?

There are people who think he's getting Goddards role

Unfortianetly he's not getting Goddards No 1 draft pick talent

Haha nice. ;D

Classic.  8)

True, but also very harsh. Watch out for this kid cos he is going to be a quality player and has a good leg on him. Will go into the Goddard role and while he may not play with Goddard ability, he's in a prime position on the park to rack up the numbers, thats why hes so popular.

Well if we are going by these assumptions.... Richard Tambling is going to play a similar role to Goddard but for Adelaide, aaaand he was a higher draft pick then BUDDY! Aaaaaand hes $200k cheaper.... Yet no love. ;)

[blues boy]

Siposs

I worry about sylvia, melbourne have brought in a lot of mids/fwds this year who are all in their best 22. While sylvia is in the best 22 all it takes is a slight role change and we now have a 65av dud

Rodan, Toumpas, Viney, Dawes, Byrnes, Terlich, Jones, Gilles all in best 22

Wow! You think 4 first year players are all better then sylvia? I find that very hard to believe!

[Jroo]

Sylvia by a very long way. He is a proven 90s average player, whose 2012 average was purely ruined from his spine injury he sustained in the NAB Cup.

Watts and Siposs are both unproven, although I think Watts could be a possible 85 average, but still a big risk.

Sylvia >>> Watts > Siposs IMO.

Yeah +1 Adam
Sylvia is a gun and will be in the top 10 forwards if he stays fit. Flyer his bye in round 13 he was on fire for the rest of the year, which shows he's a gun when he's fit. Plus he's not too expensive, lock him in over Watts or Siposs. If you really want Watts then chuck him down back