Grimes Vs Hartlett Vs Hanley

[quinny88]

Without trying to crystal ball who will get injured. Who do you think will score the most in 2013 if they all play a full season?

[tbagrocks]

Hartlett, a fit Hamish could see anything
Grimes
Hanley

[meow meow]

Hartlett is the most talented of the 3 and his ceiling is pretty high. His game against Carlton was one of the top 10 performances by any player last year. A few more games like that and he could challenge for the #1 defender spot in SC.

[quinny88]

Hartlett is the most talented of the 3 and his ceiling is pretty high. His game against Carlton was one of the top 10 performances by any player last year. A few more games like that and he could challenge for the #1 defender spot in SC.

Yeah I remember that game, he killed em

[ando_10]

hartlett for mine. if he stays fit he will average low 100s

[Southstorm]

Hartlett is the most talented of the 3 and his ceiling is pretty high. His game against Carlton was one of the top 10 performances by any player last year. A few more games like that and he could challenge for the #1 defender spot in SC.

^This. Hartlett will most likely have the best average of the three by the end of the year. If Port becomes even a marginally better team then that should help things a bit as well.   

[quinny88]

Everyone saying Hartlett in the comments yet he has the least amount of votes? lol

[gunnerzzz]

Impossible to say. Hartlett is due for a big year, but he is so injury prone! Would make a nice POD if you're up for the risk. I reckon everyone will be too scared to pick him due to being injury prone. 30 trades maybe start him and if he goes down, trade to Hanley.

[Jay]

Hanley is in like 3% of teams or something ridiculous. I'm going him for uniqueness

[quinny88]

Impossible to say. Hartlett is due for a big year, but he is so injury prone! Would make a nice POD if you're up for the risk. I reckon everyone will be too scared to pick him due to being injury prone. 30 trades maybe start him and if he goes down, trade to Hanley.

I did say injuries aside though. Pointless trying to speculate who may or may not get injured

Hanley is in like 3% of teams or something ridiculous. I'm going him for uniqueness

Can he finish top 6 mids though? Can any of these guys?

[shorty3264]

Yeh he's trailing in the poll....haha

I went with Grimes, I think he will step into the dees midfield and show his true potential. Toss of the coin between Hartlett and him though.

[Millhouse]

I think they'll both be pretty good. I think Hartlett will be a better performer in a better performing team

[FactHunt]

HH. This is the year I have been waiting for for this guy... had him on the radar since he was drafted in '08, reckon he is gonna be a jet (of course he needs an injury free run at it). But as far a ceiling goes, he is the cream here.

HH>Grimes>Hanley (barring injury)

[Ricochet]

Based on early fixture and Brissie fans saying he will push up to a wing this year, I'm gonna run with Hanley.
Last years scores:
WB 151, 117
ADE 92 (he actually loves playing Adelaide :o ... career average of 103)
SUNS 114, 109
NORTH 112
MELB 124, 104
SYD 119


Port boys... where is Hartlett looking like playing? Will he be back in the middle or continue his halfback role?

[tbagrocks]

I have heard a player and coach say through the midfield