Thoughts on Shane Mumford??

[SydneyRox]

Tempted but reluctant, maybe for my SC, see how he goes next two weeks

Is he over the injured back? If so then a decent pick

his back was never injured, his back issues was to do with reactions to injections. his hammy is what started to give and pinged on GF day

[tbagrocks]

Tempted but reluctant, maybe for my SC, see how he goes next two weeks

Is he over the injured back? If so then a decent pick

his back was never injured, his back issues was to do with reactions to injections. his hammy is what started to give and pinged on GF day

When he did go out and Sandi went down, I waited for the Mummy return and price drop the got him in, was good for me late in the year, very tempted atm, it's either McEvoey or Mumford

[Capper]

Tempted but reluctant, maybe for my SC, see how he goes next two weeks

Is he over the injured back? If so then a decent pick

his back was never injured, his back issues was to do with reactions to injections. his hammy is what started to give and pinged on GF day

When he did go out and Sandi went down, I waited for the Mummy return and price drop the got him in, was good for me late in the year, very tempted atm, it's either McEvoey or Mumford

I do believe it is leg or hamstring issues at the moment, dont think he will play NAB this year

[tbagrocks]

Well he's cheap very cheap, will he make round one? Thoughts on starting him?

[Capper]

Well he's cheap very cheap, will he make round one? Thoughts on starting him?

i think they are arent playing him so he is right for R1, but if he doesnt play i think White comes in

Wait and see

[blues boy]

Is he over the injured back? If so then a decent pick

his back was never injured, his back issues was to do with reactions to injections. his hammy is what started to give and pinged on GF day
[/quote]

When he did go out and Sandi went down, I waited for the Mummy return and price drop the got him in, was good for me late in the year, very tempted atm, it's either McEvoey or Mumford
[/quote]


Yeah same here! I want to go Mumford as i believe he is probably the better ruckman however McEvoy is a consistent ruckman!

[ronl]

Hey Tbags, what's wrong with Sam Jacobs, is there something we should know?

[Windigo]

I've been keen all pre-season.

8 score over 80+ from 14 games. Good draw, better than Goldy.

[tbagrocks]

Hey Tbags, what's wrong with Sam Jacobs, is there something we should know?

Just that he doesn't get asmuch ball as the top DT ruckmen, but for a solid consistant 85-90 with durability and hastle free

Sauce would be your man, but for me he doesn't score highly enough

[Adamant]

Not going near Mummy after last year. Way too injury prone and I know we can risk injury prone guys with 44 trades... BUT he doesn't even score 'Sandi-like' numbers to compensate his inability to stay on the park.

At least when people were picking Sandi it was because he is a 100 average player when fit. Mummy's highest average is only 91, which is great, but not enough when he is that injury prone IMO.

[Windigo]

In his breakout year he have 3 score over 130+ showing his massive ceiling, no consistency however.

But then you look at last year he added some consistency to his game, the last 5 games not going under 80.

[Holz]

he is cheap and is a good pick. but for 80k more cox just provides another level of safety and scoring potential.

[stew42]

he is cheap and is a good pick. but for 80k more cox just provides another level of safety and scoring potential.

Yeah, only 80k...  ::)

[Windigo]

80 K is a lot to find.  :P

[Holz]

80 K is a lot to find.  :P

for me it was robbo down to cloke.

or boyd down to murphy etc...