Please Rate this Gun Side, now even stronger

[Cashman]

Check out this gun side. Please advise what you think?

B - H.Shaw, Bock, C Cornes, Adcock, O'Brien, Rains, Hill, E - Rance, Suban

C- Ablett, Judd, Swan, Tuck, Higgins Rich, E  - Dangerfield, Beams

R - Sandilands, Hille - E -Graham Currie

F - Pavilich, Deledio, S Johnston, Roughead, T Cloke, Anthony, Ziebell E -Sidebottom, Grant
$76,400 still remaining

[cooney17]

Got to work cox into there

[Watto]

Hille out for McIntosh, then Sandilands for Cox

[Cashman]

I am $23,200 short if i take out Sandilands to get Cox.

Do you think McIntosh will play consistent football this year?

I still have $76,400 remaining in salary cap. Any other options to get Cox in?

Would love your advise.

[Watto]

Who do you want to get rid off from your ruck to get Cox?

[Cashman]

Watto, I would get rid of Sandilands. That would leave me $23,200 to get Cox. Don't really want to down grade Hille.

Any suggestions who else to down grade for make up the $23,200

[Watto]

Sorry i've been offline for a while...

You could remove O'brien for Jesse Smith/Houlihan/Hansen

Or Swan for Richo/K. Cornes/Bolton

Which Tuck do you have? Shane or Travis?

If Shane trade of for Selwood, and Travis for T. Selwood/Slattery

[Alex7089]

Sorry i've been offline for a while...

You could remove O'brien for Jesse Smith/Houlihan/Hansen

Or Swan for Richo/K. Cornes/Bolton

Which Tuck do you have? Shane or Travis?

If Shane trade of for Selwood, and Travis for T. Selwood/Slattery

Cornes may not be needed to win the ball at port this year he may be used as a tagger do you really want to take this risk?
Why not Gibbs?
Travis Tuck should be a good cash cow this year don't get rid of him for Tyson or Henry Slattery!He will be better than both of 'em.
Shane Tuck will be good too ( hopefully) hes the right age and with Foley and Cousins around him he will not cop the tag. (again hopefully)
I agree with the tADE OF O'Brien for Houlihan (Ryan??)hes not a huge scorer but should be better than O'Brian (Harry??)

[Watto]

So which Tuck do u have???

With Shane Tuck + Bryce Gibbs they have other good players around them (for S.T. - Cousins, Foley, Richo, Simmonds, Vickery, Brown)(and B.G. has Judd, Murphy, Kreuzer, Scotland, Stevens, Bentick)

So yes, they won't get the best tagger every week, but with all these other guys around them sucking up the possessions, they won't get the ball as much either



Travis Tuck already costs $327,100, so as a cash cow he isn't gunna go up too much higher. Like Gibbs and S. Tuck, he has good players around him (mainly Mitchell, Hodge, Bateman, Sewell) who will get the ball a lot, so he'll miss out a bit as well.
There are plenty of young midfield recruits (Redden, Robinson, Skipworth, Zaharakis, Hartlett,  Hannebery, Connors) who are cheaper, and so have the potential to go up higher in price, i.e. be better cash cows

(Ryan) Houlihan isnt gunna score that much, but he's under 300,000 and will probably do better than (Harry) O'Brien (H.O'B. is just under 350,000),
so you're saving some cash by getting R.H. over H.O'B.

[Queenslander]

t cloke out for krakouer/skipworth

tuck out for harding/skipworth

swan out for pendlebury/gibbs/murphy

hille out for cox

obrien out for malceski/grimes

[Alex7089]

Watto, Skippy was a mature age recruit, not a young mid.

[Cashman]

Thanks for your feed back. I have made the following changes.
Out Sandilands  - in Cox
Out O'brien - in Houlihan
with $25,400 remaining.
Side looks like this now
B - H.Shaw, Bock, C Cornes, Adcock, Houlihan, Rains, Hill, E - Rance, Suban

C- Ablett, Judd, Swan, T Tuck, Higgins Rich, E  - Dangerfield, Beams

R - Cox , Hille - E -Graham Currie

F - Pavilich, Deledio, S Johnston, Roughead, T Cloke, Anthony, Ziebell E -Sidebottom, Grant
Let me know if there are another changes I can make to make this side stronger? I have Travis Tuck in centre

[Watto]

Might not be a good idea to have both Cloke and Anthony, coz if Collingwood lose, then you lose.

Also, Anthony had that one awesome game in the NAB Cup, but he probably isn't gunna be able to perform like that every week. But he is likely to rise in price a bit if he has just 1 or 2 of those sorts of games this year, so he might be an ok cash cow.

Cloke is quite expensive, for just under his price you could get Lonergan/C. Rioli/Osborne/Bate, but its up to you. Maybe even go down to Lucas ($338,600)?

This would free up a few $$, so then if you trade Anthony you could get someone a bit higher, which is quite a lot when you're right up the top end.
In addition to your $25,400, this would mean you then have over $100,000, so maybe upgrade H. Shaw to a gun (Goddard/Fisher/Bowden/Enright)

[Richo_Richo_Man]

allowing for 30pts re rookies...ur lookin at total 1827 with ablett as capt....some r claiming >2000 proj.

Like me I think u need to rework...I've got mine to 1857...and still workin!! GL.

[fyfebe]

predicted totals mean nothing.