Roos V Demons V Tigers NAB Cup discussion

[Mat0369]

I know it is only pre-season, but how does Luke McGuane get a game? I still remember that game last year where he missed twice from the goal square.

[Mat0369]

And to quote Juicy Brucie, Daniel Wells was delicious right there.

[tyronee]

How did lids and Cotchin play? What roles etc

[LF]

would`nt read much into lids and cotchins 2nd game they spent the 2nd half of the 2nd game on the bench

[Mat0369]

would`nt read much into lids and cotchins 2nd game they spent the 2nd half of the 2nd game on the bench

Agreed. The more experienced guys don't really need to come out and tear it up. It is more about the rookies and younger guys and seeing how they fit in

[LF]

would`nt read much into lids and cotchins 2nd game they spent the 2nd half of the 2nd game on the bench

Agreed. The more experienced guys don't really need to come out and tear it up. It is more about the rookies and younger guys and seeing how they fit in

Tigers did well without them too looks like they are getting some depth in the team

[tbagrocks]

Plus Mullet, Houli and Tuck DNP game two

[Colliwobblers]

Currie and Daw both looked and scored significantly better than Goldspud - no surprises there.

it's just nab cup but cotchin..... meh  with adelaide, sydney brisbane and essendon all having easier draws early I can't see myself starting him.

[Grazz]

Im interested to see how the masses feel about running with Goldy now. Bit unfair to mark to harshly i'll reserve any real critical judgement when they are playing full games and even then NAB can be misleading. As Mat said you learn more about the rookies than anybody else really in these half games.

[Samm79]

One...... Pre........ Season....... Game........... Only............ People...........

[LF]

Im interested to see how the masses feel about running with Goldy now. Bit unfair to mark to harshly i'll reserve any real critical judgement when they are playing full games and even then NAB can be misleading. As Mat said you learn more about the rookies than anybody else really in these half games.

Yeah Goldstein unimpressive but you`d need to see him in a full game before any judgement

[Grazz]

Im interested to see how the masses feel about running with Goldy now. Bit unfair to mark to harshly i'll reserve any real critical judgement when they are playing full games and even then NAB can be misleading. As Mat said you learn more about the rookies than anybody else really in these half games.

Yeah Goldstein unimpressive but you`d need to see him in a full game before any judgement

Absolutely LF, even then NAB can still be misleading.

[Colliwobblers]

Im interested to see how the masses feel about running with Goldy now. Bit unfair to mark to harshly i'll reserve any real critical judgement when they are playing full games and even then NAB can be misleading. As Mat said you learn more about the rookies than anybody else really in these half games.

Yeah Goldstein unimpressive but you`d need to see him in a full game before any judgement

I saw goldy in enough full games last season to pass judgement - and yes Hmac was already out.

To be fair he is capable of being a solid premium SC ruckman i just shake my head at those that intend to start him in DT type comps.

Doesnt win possessions, doesn't tackle, doesn't run, doesn't kick goals. IS A GREAT TAP RUCKMAN ON HIS DAY. SC loves that.

The fact is you saw Maric the next game, wins his own ball, works hard, great second effort, marks kicks , goals, gets involved in the play as they switch, TACKLES. Gun - better ruckman? maybe - better footballer? definitely.

just one little opinion tho :)

[quinny88]

Easy on the Richmond bashing mat lol
They went out and had a crack. How is that a bad thing?

[Grazz]

Im interested to see how the masses feel about running with Goldy now. Bit unfair to mark to harshly i'll reserve any real critical judgement when they are playing full games and even then NAB can be misleading. As Mat said you learn more about the rookies than anybody else really in these half games.

Yeah Goldstein unimpressive but you`d need to see him in a full game before any judgement

I saw goldy in enough full games last season to pass judgement - and yes Hmac was already out.

To be fair he is capable of being a solid premium SC ruckman i just shake my head at those that intend to start him in DT type comps.

Doesnt win possessions, doesn't tackle, doesn't run, doesn't kick goals. IS A GREAT TAP RUCKMAN ON HIS DAY. SC loves that.

The fact is you saw Maric the next game, wins his own ball, works hard, great second effort, marks kicks , goals, gets involved in the play as they switch, TACKLES. Gun - better ruckman? maybe - better footballer? definitely.

just one little opinion tho :)

But a good and respected opinion Colli.