Would appreciate your opinion

[nperera95]

Hey there fellow supercoachers. This is my 3rd year playing Supercoach and I would like your help/opinion and a rate on my current side :)

Backs: B.Goddard, B.Gibbs, H.Hartlett, P.Hanley, B.Staker, J.Pittard  Bench: S.Docherty, D.Terlich

Mid: G.Abett, D.Swan, J.Watson, T.Cotchin, B.Moloney, L.Ball, O.Wines, B.Crouch  Bench: B.Goodes, J.Viney

Ruck: T.Goldstein, M.Leuenberger  Bench: S.Rowe, M.Daw

Forwards: L.Franklin, T.Rockliff, T.Hawkins, A.Monfries, S.Mayes, B.Macaffer  Bench: J. Daniher, T.Lee

Cash left: $23,000

[ben_020285]

BACKS: 4 potential keepers here which is good to see. Here's hoping Hartlett can remain injury free and Hanley can truly breakout this year, he certainly has the potential to do so.

MIDS: 4 solid super prems but one too many mid pricers for mine. I would choose one of Moloney or Ball and downgrade the other to O'Meara. He is a must especially at his price.

RUCKS: Standard, no issues here.

FWDS: 3 good keeper choices here. Hawkins will have a low score here and there as he is a KPP but I still think he can push a 110 average this year. Not a fan of the Monfries pick, will he be a keeper? No. Will he increase his average enough to be a decent cash cow? Unlikely. I would upgrade Monfries to a keeper with the cash used from downgrading either Moloney or Ball to a rookie. I would also try to get either Byrnes or Varcoe in for one of your fwd rookies if you can.

Currently you have 13 potential keepers, if you can increase that to 14 keepers then it will be a very solid side. 8/10.

[Crouchy182]

Ok so things that stick out to me is the inclusion of Moloney and Ball, i would consider downgrading one to O'meara and upgrading the other to Fyfe/Mundy. You don't want to miss O'meara as Ben said and Fyfe or Mundy could be a potential M8 keeper.

Staker had mionor knee surgery and will miss the first few roundsi would keep an eye on the Nab but suggest Goodes if he gets his senior promotion.

The other thing to consider is your fwd and def structure with 4 prem def and 3 fwd prems(not counting Monfries as i think he is a risky pick) I propose with the better rookies in the back line it would be better to trade one of your back prems to a rookie to bolster the forward line, as the forward rookie cupboard is bare)

The omission of Cox is interesting, not everyone wants him but as a suggestion that if you do, trade Monfries to Varcoe/Knights/Byrnes who imo should score similarly to Monfries and upgrade Walker. Cox may be handy for flexibility since you already have Rowe.

[nperera95]

Ok so things that stick out to me is the inclusion of Moloney and Ball, i would consider downgrading one to O'meara and upgrading the other to Fyfe/Mundy. You don't want to miss O'meara as Ben said and Fyfe or Mundy could be a potential M8 keeper.

Staker had mionor knee surgery and will miss the first few roundsi would keep an eye on the Nab but suggest Goodes if he gets his senior promotion.

The other thing to consider is your fwd and def structure with 4 prem def and 3 fwd prems(not counting Monfries as i think he is a risky pick) I propose with the better rookies in the back line it would be better to trade one of your back prems to a rookie to bolster the forward line, as the forward rookie cupboard is bare)

The omission of Cox is interesting, not everyone wants him but as a suggestion that if you do, trade Monfries to Varcoe/Knights/Byrnes who imo should score similarly to Monfries and upgrade Walker. Cox may be handy for flexibility since you already have Rowe.

BACKS: 4 potential keepers here which is good to see. Here's hoping Hartlett can remain injury free and Hanley can truly breakout this year, he certainly has the potential to do so.

MIDS: 4 solid super prems but one too many mid pricers for mine. I would choose one of Moloney or Ball and downgrade the other to O'Meara. He is a must especially at his price.

RUCKS: Standard, no issues here.

FWDS: 3 good keeper choices here. Hawkins will have a low score here and there as he is a KPP but I still think he can push a 110 average this year. Not a fan of the Monfries pick, will he be a keeper? No. Will he increase his average enough to be a decent cash cow? Unlikely. I would upgrade Monfries to a keeper with the cash used from downgrading either Moloney or Ball to a rookie. I would also try to get either Byrnes or Varcoe in for one of your fwd rookies if you can.

Currently you have 13 potential keepers, if you can increase that to 14 keepers then it will be a very solid side. 8/10.

Cheers Ben and Crouchy  :)
I've taken your advice and this is what my side looks like now thanks to yous;

Defenders: B.Goddard, B.Gibbs, H.Hartlett, P.Hanley, B.Goodes, J.Pittard  Bench: D.Terlich, S.Docherty

Midfielders: G.Ablett, D.Swan, J.Watson, T.Cotchin, N.Fyfe, K.Mitchell, B.Crouch, J.O'Merara  Bench: J.Viney, J.Neade

Rucks: T.Goldstein, M.Leuenberger  Bench: S.Rowe, M.Daw

Forwards: D.Cox, T.Rockliff, T.Hawkins, D.Martin, S.Mayes, B.Macaffer  Bench: J.Daniher, T.Lee

Team looks more balanced thanks to you boys. I'm not too sure on Martin but hopefully he gets back to his full potential.

[nperera95]

any more room for improvement?

[Ringo]

Solid changes made - Team more balanced.

Just watch rookies to ensure they are named - Mayes I do not think will make 1st round

Good luck for 2013 and well done with changes.

[Crouchy182]

Solid changes made - Team more balanced.

Just watch rookies to ensure they are named - Mayes I do not think will make 1st round

Good luck for 2013 and well done with changes.

+1 agree with the team changes, rookie watch and sentiment good luck!!

[tor01doc]

Definitely better after your changes.

Only thing I'd try is Fyfe to say Ball and Martin to Buddy.

See want that looks like and if Fyfe kills it I reckon you'll still be able afford him by using a cash cow.

It is really nice to see Buddy in your team.

[ben_020285]

Looks great now mate.

If you can try to squeeze either Byrnes or Varcoe into your fwd line by changing some of your expensive rookies to cheaper ones then it would be very close to perfection.

[nperera95]

cheers guys. Goodluck to you boys this supercoach! :)