UPDATED TEAM

Started by Quinn413, February 20, 2013, 11:11:11 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Quinn413

Back: B.Goddard, B.Gibbs, G.Birchall, N.Vlastuin, B.Goodes, D.Terlich (S.Colquhoun, J.Saunders)
Mid: G.Ablett, D.Swan, S.Pendelbury, S.Thompson, N.Fyfe, D.Hannebery, J.O'Meara, J.Viney (B.Crouch, T.Mitchell)
Rucks: S.Jacobs, M.Luenberger (J.Witts, D.Currie)
Forwards: L.Franklin, T.Walker, T.Rockliff, T.Hawkins, B.Macaffer, T.Lee (J.Growden, R.Atkins)
Salary Cap: 30,900

BB67th

Really great team there mate, very solid all around and nice structure. 8.5/10

I think you may be just a little too heavy in the mids. I would probably downgrade Hannebery to a rookie, and maybe look at someone like Broughton in the backline. But I guess that is your choice, seeing as starting with 8 mids now you can go for that extra scoring power, and I like Hannebery as a unique pick.

I also don't think Jacobs is a really solid R1 and I would go for someone like a Goldstein or McIntosh instead.

monga77

Quote from: BB67th on February 20, 2013, 11:46:58 PM

I also don't think Jacobs is a really solid R1 and I would go for someone like a Goldstein or McIntosh instead.
Interesting opinion! I think Jacobs is a great pick, Adelaide are going to be a force again this year and think Jacobs will smash it! Mcintosh a very risky pick with the injury factor! Goldstein a very mainstream choice so stick with Jacobs

Quinn413

Is Tom Lee and Dean Terlich going to play R1?

Millhouse

#4
I think Jacobs is a great R1 option; he is one of the top-tier rucks and the new ruck scores may help him - a reliable and robust POD
He may be more reliable than McIntosh, Goldstein or Mumford (or others of vaguely the same price range)

Crouchy182

I think your mids are far too stacked. The reason behind this being simply is cash cows. Most people are going for as few possible fwd rookies playing because there are a lack of viable forward rookies who have good js and should score consistently. Your Mid rookies are where the money is at and having only 4 i think will disadvantage you in the $$ department heavily. That aside i like your choice of premiums and i think this team will start strongly but may not go the distance.