Which option?

[GraysFan]

Just wondering who would be better, currently my midfield are;
Ablett, Pendles, Deledio, Murphy, Fyfe, Gaff, Lonergan, Omeara, Crouch and Viney

My forwards are;
Cox, Rockliffe, Martin, Knights, Brynes, Macaffer, Lee, Neade

I have 4 prems and 4 rooks down back along with the standard ruck combo.

[Jukes]

Wright 92, Kane 80
vs
Gaff 92, Tommy 60

Kane and Matty comfortably imo.

[Money]

I prefer Martin to Wright but in this case Wright and K.Mitchell

[Colliwobblers]

Wright 92, Kane 80
vs
Gaff 92, Tommy 60

Kane and Matty comfortably imo.

think Gaff will improve sufficiently to not make it so  "comfortably" :) but yeah i agree with Jukes

[Jukes]

Wright 92, Kane 80
vs
Gaff 92, Tommy 60

Kane and Matty comfortably imo.

think Gaff will improve sufficiently to not make it so  "comfortably" :) but yeah i agree with Jukes

Can't see Gaff improving enough to beat Wright by 20 points to make up for Kane beating Tommy by that much :P

[GraysFan]

I prefer Martin to Wright but in this case Wright and K.Mitchell

If you looked at my mids and forwards that i put up (to avoid this), you would see i already have martin.

[GraysFan]

Wright 92, Kane 80
vs
Gaff 92, Tommy 60

Kane and Matty comfortably imo.

think Gaff will improve sufficiently to not make it so  "comfortably" :) but yeah i agree with Jukes

Can't see Gaff improving enough to beat Wright by 20 points to make up for Kane beating Tommy by that much :P

Thanks guys :) Im a bit half-hearted with gaff because if he improves more he will cop the tag and thatll get rid of a lot of his uncontested possestions thats he's so good at getting

[Colliwobblers]

Gaff will average 105-115 this season  :o

he averages one tackle a game ( one and a bit) due to his outside role, he was tagged last season, he will be again this season, not sure it will matter.

Pick 4 in his 3rd year = BOOM

not starting him myself but if he gets a couple more possessions a game ( averaged 25) kicks a little more 16 kicks - 9 handballs (AVG)

and lays one more tackle per game and maybe kick a goal more often (9 for the seasonin 2012) he will be ELITE.

only 10 FF too he is at West Coast i mean come on man duck your head ! and there is a few more points per game  :o

sorry Eagles fans :)

[Money]

I prefer Martin to Wright but in this case Wright and K.Mitchell

If you looked at my mids and forwards that i put up (to avoid this), you would see i already have martin.

Mate just saying I prefer Martin, whether hes already there or not

[GraysFan]

I prefer Martin to Wright but in this case Wright and K.Mitchell

If you looked at my mids and forwards that i put up (to avoid this), you would see i already have martin.

Mate just saying I prefer Martin, whether hes already there or not

okays. just read what i said again, sorry if i sounded hostile, wasnt my intention..

[Money]

I prefer Martin to Wright but in this case Wright and K.Mitchell

If you looked at my mids and forwards that i put up (to avoid this), you would see i already have martin.

Mate just saying I prefer Martin, whether hes already there or not

okays. just read what i said again, sorry if i sounded hostile, wasnt my intention..

All good mate

[Adamant]

Wright and Kane for me.

[tbagrocks]

Neither, but Wright is a lock and Gaff could be your smokie

Those two rooks will stuggle to score/play

[Jalapeno]

Neither, but Wright is a lock and Gaff could be your smokie

Those two rooks will stuggle to score/play

Like the idea of going with both. Wright is a lock IMO and i think gaff could explode!

Also think you need K Mitchell in your team he will be a great rookie who scores well... given the opportunity :)

[timmyparso]

Two points about Kane Mitchell after NAB round 1:
1. yes, he can get plenty of the ball
2. his kicking and disposal is TERRIBLE!!!!!!!!!!!

Most of his disposals average, creating 50/50 chances at best for Port or floated into open space. If this doesn't improve He'll be playing most of the year in the SANFL. Kane may average 70 but will take twice as long for his price to rise than a Viney/Wines/Crouch/O'mera as he will play less games.