First Draft Team - Second Year SCer

IPCoach · February 17, 2013, 03:45:00 PM

Would love to hear your thoughts - Inexperienced SCer here!
$106,000 left

Cheers Everyone!

colmullet · February 17, 2013, 03:56:26 PM

Backs: Waters in under an injury cloud over the pre-season, Scotland will miss the first two games of the season with club imposed ban. I think there are also better options than Rance for that price. The rest look fine

Mids: Thomas is injured and likely to eithe rmiss a few or start quite slowly, others all looks fine

Rucks: Jenkins is interesting...should improve but not to the point of being a premier ruckmen.....Pederson on the bench is a lot of money to have sitting off the field aswell

Fwds: Pav has had surgery and injury concerns over the offseason so look out there. Bock is also set to miss the start of the season with his injury. Jessy white isnt a great choice, can't see him playing much with Mummy, Pyke, Tippet, Reid all there as big men in front of him in the queue. Again Wiliams is a lot of money to have sitting on the bench

Keep fiddling with it man, plenty of time till round 1 :)

Popey99 · February 17, 2013, 04:12:22 PM

DEF: Goddard in for Waters, Gibbs in for Scotland and Birchall in for Rance and it looks great.
MID: Upgarde Thomas to Murphy. Rest is OK. Stevens could become Kane Lucas for an extra 40k. He is in ripping form in the Intra-club matches. Or you could downgrade Stevens to one of Tom or Kane Mitchell.
RUC: Jenkins is one I've seen in a couple of teams... To be honest I'd drop Pedersen to a rookie and take Jenkins to Mumford/Goldstein.
FWD: Pav is risky. Rockliff and Martin are good picks. Sippos is interesting, go for it if you want to! Bock and White can become Byrnes and Varcoe if you are looking for mid-pricers there. Williams should become a rookie.

Good work mate. Keep tinkering! :) If you want a look at some experienced SCers teams for structures, pop over to Colmullets or my RMT's. (This is my 5th year!) They give a good indication of how to set out your team and get the right mix of rookies, mid pricers and premium players. Essentially, all bench spots should be filled with players under 150k.

Good luck!!

IPCoach · February 17, 2013, 06:23:26 PM

Oh cheers for that guys, Have paid 0 attention to off/preseason.... flatout work and newborn bubs!

Pretty pleased with this feedback though Ill have a squizz at some of those suggestions and re post

Whats your thoughts on NicNat?

colmullet · February 17, 2013, 06:26:04 PM

NicNat is injured and is likely to miss the first few of the season aswell, perfect upgrade target ;)

IPCoach · February 17, 2013, 06:27:34 PM

Cheers bud

IPCoach · February 17, 2013, 06:50:19 PM

Im left with 280k

It def needs more work!

Popey99 · February 17, 2013, 10:39:47 PM

Much better! Nice work mate! Good luck with the bubs too!! Scotland will miss the first 2 games with a club imposed suspension by the way... Might wanna look elsewhere.

IPCoach · February 17, 2013, 10:47:08 PM

Cheers mate... being a dad is top notch I love it!
Scotland ... gooow.
qQuick question if he or any other player didn't play do they lose value after 3 weeks?

Popey99 · February 17, 2013, 11:33:29 PM

No, once a player PLAYS 3 games they either increase or decrease in value, so once Scotland has served his suspension he won't have changed in value at all unfortunately.