Selwood VS Murphy

[hardnut]

Selwood: 109
Murphy: 106

Selwood.

Do you have a crystal ball or something? Your score predictions are so confident. I reckon you should keep them in a list somewhere and see how they pan-out. If your even 80% right you should be driving a new Toyota  at years end.

[Ricochet]

Selwood: 109
Murphy: 106

Selwood.

lol

[tbagrocks]

Selwood: 109
Murphy: 106

Selwood.

Selwood 105
Murphy 112

Murphy

[Jukes]

Selwood: 109
Murphy: 106

Selwood.

Do you have a crystal ball or something? Your score predictions are so confident. I reckon you should keep them in a list somewhere and see how they pan-out. If your even 80% right you should be driving a new Toyota  at years end.

nah mate won't get a toyota

They're giving away 50k to the winrar this season

[Ricochet]

Selwood: 109
Murphy: 106

Selwood.

Selwood 105
Murphy 112

Murphy

thats more like it

[nrich102]

Murphy by miles

[B.S]

Selwood: 109
Murphy: 106

Selwood.

Do you have a crystal ball or something? Your score predictions are so confident. I reckon you should keep them in a list somewhere and see how they pan-out. If your even 80% right you should be driving a new Toyota  at years end.

nah mate won't get a toyota

They're giving away 50k to the winrar this season

bahahahahaaha  love it jukes, love it ;D

[rebird]

Selwood: 109
Murphy: 106

Selwood.

scott or joel? original q was joel

[Jukes]

Selwood: 109
Murphy: 106

Selwood.

scott or joel? original q was joel

I was referring to Joel. Scott won't make it over 100.

[Hippo]

Selwood: 109
Murphy: 106

Selwood.

scott or joel? original q was joel

I was referring to Joel. Scott won't make it over 100.

he will, he won't and so on and on and on

you dribble anymore you will sink in it

[mezzoculo]

Ha ha. Crystal balls everywhere! ;D

If you compare recent averages (i.e. 2011 - 2012) against early season opponents for the two of them, this is the result...

Average against first 6 opponents:
Murphy - 112
Selwood - 113

Average against first 11 opponents:
Murphy - 109
Selwood - 115

These numbers exclude games where either player was injured and don't take into account venue.
So, stats say much of a muchness. Just depends upon who each of us predict (i.e. GUESS) will have the better natural improvement this season.

[azza707]

Geelong COULD potentially slide a bit this year. everyone is just that one year older. Selwood relies so much on his contested footy and if Geelong are being beaten in that category then he may struggle. Ive picked him the last few seasons and watched him struggle more and more each year that goes past to rack it up like he did in his first few years.

Murphy under Malthouse could be very interesting. I think he could very well thrive similar to the likes of Beams/Sidey/Swan. With Judd and the emergence of McClean as inside midfielders, think Murphy could be in for a big year. only worry is his limited pre season.

[Nige]

Murphy > Selwood for me.

[Chopps]

while selwood has the potential he always has a game a season where he is ko'd

out of the two i d say murphy.

[Nige]

while selwood has the potential he always has a game a season where he is ko'd

out of the two i d say murphy.

Whenever he's been in my team, I've always been able to rely on him to get me good scores. But the weeks I most wanted great scores from him he'd cop a knock. So annoying. :P