Selwood VS Murphy

Started by B.S, February 15, 2013, 06:43:34 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Same price, Same numbers???

Joel Selwood
5 (20%)
Marc Murphy
20 (80%)

Total Members Voted: 2

B.S

Both the key mids at their clubs this year. Both priced similarly, could selwood be a better buy?

Adamant

*Waits for Jukes to call Murphy a spud and go Jelwood as a unique*

B.S

Quote from: Adamant on February 15, 2013, 06:53:37 PM
*Waits for Jukes to call Murphy a spud and go Jelwood as a unique*
YES, have seen it a few times, but only from him so far this season

Ricochet

Quote from: Adamant on February 15, 2013, 06:53:37 PM
*Waits for Jukes to call Murphy a spud and go Jelwood as a unique*
haha

Hippo

mush of a muchness at the end of the day

Pick the one you enjoy watching the most

Jalapeno

Quote from: Hippo on February 15, 2013, 06:59:37 PM
mush of a muchness at the end of the day

Pick the one you enjoy watching the most

So either you like watching murphy play footy orrr

you like watching selwood play "how low can you go"... Its limbo time haha

GM

Both are great to watch.
Selwood nearly always misses games.
I usually have Selwood in SC because of his consistency.
But Murphy in DT for me.

B.S

suprisingly that has actually helped me make my decision.
Had to put this up for my mate who loves selwood but wasnt sure whether murphy would be better.
Thanks lads

Master Q

Murphy for me. Underpriced at an average of 100-101? But actually averaged 106 last season if you exclude his injury effected game.

The_Captain


SydneyRox

Murphy for me. reckon he is a good 5-10 points better than selwood

Toga

Yep as everyone has said so far it's Murphy for me too. Selwood is too much of a KO risk for me for starters!

hardnut

Scott Selwood  ;)

But Murphy in that contest even though Joel is a fav of mine just seems to have lost the big ceiling

Hippo

Quote from: hardnut on February 16, 2013, 02:00:44 AM
Scott Selwood  ;)

But Murphy in that contest even though Joel is a fav of mine just seems to have lost the big ceiling
Totally agree  ;)

Jukes

Selwood: 109
Murphy: 106

Selwood.