Take a look and rate!

Started by Dylbags, February 15, 2013, 02:22:02 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Dylbags

Goddard, Gibbs, Duffield, Goodes, Pittard, Docherty
Terlich, Colquhoun

Ablett, Swan, Cotchin, Selwood, Murphy, Maloney, O'Meara, Viney
Mitchell, Crouch

Goldstein, Leuenberger
Currie, Mcbean

Franklin, Cox, Rockliff, Varcoe, Macaffer, Lee
Kerridge, Staker

$246,000
Im aware that Staker is currently injured

johnnytheboy1

First of all you have too much money Sitting there
Backs: Solid enough with 3 premiums just need to watch the rookies whether they get early games.
Mids: Downgrade Moloney to Wines or Lonergan as you have spent too much in this position
Forwards: Bit Light here also so i would try and upgrade to someone like Wright.

If you include Leuey as a Premium you have 13 Premiums in the side. So with a few minor changes you get 14 premiums which would give you a strong team to start off i give your team an 7.5/10

Ringo

Solid team to work with here

Agree #246k is a bit much cash to have sitting. Personally prefer no more than $50/75k.

Defence: 3 Prems sound - but make sure you select rookies who will play most games from Round 1.
Mids: Possibly overspent here with 5 Prems plus mid pricer.
Rucks: Standard
Fwds: Bit Light here with Varcoe at F4.

Couple of suggestions depending on overall cash situation:
Upgrade a Rookie defender to Yarran maybe.
Downgrade a prem if you wish to keep Moloney or Moloney to a Rookie Wine or Jaeger stand out at the moment but observe NAB cup.
Upgrade a rookie forward or Varcoe to a prem forward of your choice. (Hawkins, Wright, Martin, Christensen, Breust).

Your choices rate 7.5/10

Dylbags

Quote from: Ringo on February 15, 2013, 03:55:57 PM
Solid team to work with here

Agree #246k is a bit much cash to have sitting. Personally prefer no more than $50/75k.

Defence: 3 Prems sound - but make sure you select rookies who will play most games from Round 1.
Mids: Possibly overspent here with 5 Prems plus mid pricer.
Rucks: Standard
Fwds: Bit Light here with Varcoe at F4.

Couple of suggestions depending on overall cash situation:
Upgrade a Rookie defender to Yarran maybe.
Downgrade a prem if you wish to keep Moloney or Moloney to a Rookie Wine or Jaeger stand out at the moment but observe NAB cup.
Upgrade a rookie forward or Varcoe to a prem forward of your choice. (Hawkins, Wright, Martin, Christensen, Breust).

Your choices rate 7.5/10

Ive changed Maloney and Murphy to Swallow and Jesse Lonergan and upgraded Staker to Martin in my FWDS

Hippo

If it was me i would have gone Maloney too Embley and Staker too Sylvia
OR
Maloney to Embley, Varcoe too Byrnes and Staker too StevieJ

and left Murphy and be done with it!! Smurph is under priced, Swallow isn't!!!  and do you know who has the toughest yr in terms of fixtures?

Dylbags

Quote from: Hippo on February 15, 2013, 05:41:07 PM
If it was me i would have gone Maloney too Embley and Staker too Sylvia
OR
Maloney to Embley, Varcoe too Byrnes and Staker too StevieJ

and left Murphy and be done with it!! Smurph is under priced, Swallow isn't!!!  and do you know who has the toughest yr in terms of fixtures?

Murphys ability to shake a tag worries me, ive just gone back to him though, considering Boyd too