Who for D3? (Have Broughton as D4)

[hawkers65]

Who would you pick? Both are looming to head into the 2013 season as POD's. According to SC Duffman is in 3% of teams and Grimes is somewhere around the 7% mark

[mudgee]

I'm having the same dilemma between Grimes, Duffman, and Hartlett.

I've got Duffman and Hartlett marked in at this stage if that helps :)

[GM]

I have Hanley @ D3.

[Jroo]

I would say Grimes, easy draw and if he stays injury free, will be a top 3 defender.
I didn't realize that only 7% have Grimes. I have him locked into my team

[hawkers65]

I would say Grimes, easy draw and if he stays injury free, will be a top 3 defender.
I didn't realize that only 7% have Grimes. I have him locked into my team

It's due to the wide range of solid back Premo's, excluding Goddard and Gibbs, all the other back premo's like hartlett, Grimes, Duffield, Heppell, Hanley and maybe Birchall are all under the 10% mark even though they are all awesome options

[Grazz]

At this stage id go for Grimes, then watch Duffy over the NAB to see if you can save a dollar by going there.

[ronl]

I'd go for Grimes, maybe he's getting a bit stronger as he matures.  Don't like the Ross Lyon factor with Duffield.

[Ricochet]

I'd go for Grimes, maybe he's getting a bit stronger as he matures.  Don't like the Ross Lyon factor with Duffield.

Ross Lyon factor??

I'd be picking Duffman over grimes. He's severely under priced

[T Dog]

Heater  ;D