Settled on this side

[corzer03]

pretty settled on this side, what do you guys reckon:

cillers Fanplanner squad in the Super Coach competition coached by corzer03. Salary cap left: $5,000.

Brendon Goddard, Bryce Gibbs, Hamish Hartlett, Nick Vlastuin, Sam Docherty, Campbell Heath
Dylan Van Unen, Dean Terlich

Scott Pendlebury, Josh P. Kennedy, Brett Deledio, Trent Cotchin, Travis Boak, Oliver Wines, Brad Crouch, Jaeger O'Meara
Jack Viney, Sam Dwyer

Sam Jacobs, Todd Goldstein
Jarrod Witts, Jonathan Ceglar

Jarryd Roughead, Taylor Walker, Tom Rockliff, Jordan Lewis, Dustin Martin, Jake Neade
Ben Kennedy, Tim Membrey

[tor01doc]

Reckon Vlastiun will be a good one. Watch though as he's not been too popular amongst the ff faithful for some reason.

Boak - not for me. 2 Tigers in mids? Neither Ablett nor Swan?

Rucks are good.

No Cox or Buddy?

No Dusty for me and I like Lewis but he will be suspended at some point.

Overall very good but I'd ditch Boak for even Ball or Embley and grab Ablett or Swan in place of Lids who surely won't outscore either of them.

Good luck.

[johnnytheboy1]

Def: Prefer a premium an D3 so iwould look at Birchall, Grimes ,Heppell don't like campbell heath there must be better options just need to watch the Nab Cup.
MIDS: Replace Deledio with Joel Selwood or even Andrew Swallow prefer Shuey at M5
Rucks: Very Strong
Fwds: Very Strong probably should leave out Martin and bring either Mayes or Stringer

Overall: Your team has a few uniques which you need just need to pick the right ones the negative is that it is too strong up fwd which unbalances the side i give your team an 7.5/10

[tor01doc]

I must add here that I disagree with the concept of being unbalanced because of your forward line being too strong.

Look at the rookies you have to select and I am sure that you'll find more appealing cash cows in mids and def.

Accordingly, one should minimise selections of prognostically poor rookies just for 'balance'.

I would rather 10 good mid/def rookies and 3 dodgy fwd rooks than a ratio of 8 good and 5 bad but this is only a gratuitous opinion piece so do with it as you see fit.

Good luck.