Please Rate my team

[vtaced]

My first attempt. Rookies are subject to change deepening on form in NAB and opportunities..

Defenders: Goddard, H.Shaw, Scotland, Hartlett, Staker, Vlastuin (Pittard, Docherty)

Midfield: Ablett, Pendelbury, Cotchin, Fyfe, Ball, Embley, Crouch, Viney (Wines, J.O'Meara)

Rucks: Macintosh, Leunberger, (Rowe, Daw)

Forwards: Franklin, Cox, Rockliff, D.Thomas, Neade, Lee, (B.Kennedy, Membrey)

Please rate. Thanks guys

[fever]

looks excellent. fwds and backs speak for themselves, i like hmac in the ruck. only query i have is mids containing fyfe, ball and embley. it's highly unlikely all 3 will become keepers, i think you're better off unloading one of ball/embley to a rookie and banking the cash or using it elsewhere.

[johnnytheboy1]

Backs: Look Strong Just need to see whether Vlastuin can find a place in the Tigers 22.
Mids: I would downgrade Embley to a  Jessie Lonergan or Nathan Hrovat Apart from that you have a strong Midfield
Rucks: I think you need to replace Mcintosh with Goldstein.
Fwds: Iwould look for a replacement for Dale Thomas and that player is Matthew Wright.

I give your team a 7/10

[dmac07]

Solid but a few too many under a cloud for me. Scotland will miss the first 2 games, Thomas doubtful for rd1. McIntosh bit of a worry with injury too. Would swap Scotland and Thomas for other premiums. Agree having fyfe, ball and embly may be risky, think maybe 2 of the 3

[vtaced]

Took your advice on board and have made the following changes:

Defenders: Goddard, H.Shaw, Waters, Gibbs, Goodes, Staker (Pittard, Docherty)

Midfield: Ablett, Pendelbury, J.Kennedy, M.Murphy, Embley, K.Mitchell, Wines , Viney (Crouch, J.O'Meara)

Rucks: Sandilands, Leunberger, (Rowe, Grundy)

Forwards: Franklin, Cox, Rockliff, Broughton, Maccafer, Lee, (Kerridge, Membrey)

$20k left

Let me know what you think?

[colmullet]

Team looks a little better, although i think Water's has some injury problems....might be wrong there but thought i heard something.

apart from that though your team looks pretty steady, just watch those rooks

[vtaced]

Cheers. Haven't heard much about Waters, but I'll keep that in mind. I was even thinking Heppel or Grimes as a possible cheaper option. But we'll see how the nab cup plays out.