Main Menu

Which Duo

Started by hi fyfe, February 08, 2013, 11:38:51 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Which Duo

Mundy + Claye Beams
Ablett + Kane Mitchell

hi fyfe

Currently have Pendlebury Murphy Fyfe kennedy Ball in midfeld
just undecided on whether adding ablett and mitchell or david mundy and claye beams

Jay

Ablett and Mitchell for sure mate!

Escapist

I can see the appeal of the first option- but at this point the 2nd option is safer. Claye Beams, despite preseason form and hype, may be an absolute bust...and no body wants to fork out the money for that.

Try and edge Mundy into your side a little later, it'll be a few weeks before he reaches the price he's really worth (550-590k i'd assume.)

tor01doc

Yablett over the other 3 combined!

Colliwobblers

just have to start ablett. especially if you don't have Beams or Swan. Pendles is good but doesn't get the huge captainworthy spkes anywhere near as often as ablett and swan do, or Beams will this season.

Murphy could go bang this season under Mick or lose some touches to Gibbs playing in the middle, bit of an unknown but always a solid SC pick as is kennedy. Ball is a bargain and a must i reckon.

nice looking midfield you will be having, good luck for the season.

SydneyRox


enzedder

Ablett one...just get him...second player didn't come into it for me. 8)

nrich102

GAJ every day of the week

ando_10

why all of a sudden is clay beams a bit of a hot topic i didnt really find him that impressive last year? so having said that gaz and mitchell

jimmytigs

option 2,gotta have gaj & mitchell could be a huge upside bonus playing for that rabble,mundy is a crock & beams an unknown really,gotta go 2

Jroo

Would have to be Ablett and Kane Mitchell!
Awesome name btw! Hi Fyfe  ;D

Ringo

GAJ by a mile.

The hype with Beams came when he returned for last 4 games and excluding first when he was sub he averaged 98 for those games,  However to put into perspective you need to factor the opposition was Adelaide, Port and Dogs. He may break out but at that price a risk as JS is a little doubtful as well.


johnnytheboy1

I agree with all Ablett has to be in most teams  plus Mundy is likely to get injured again so the ablett & Mitchell option is streets ahead.

thewizz

Ablett #1. Fill in the gaps for the rest!

quinny88

option A= 1 vote
option 2= 28 votes

Haha that tells the story..

I think the one person that voted Mundy/Beams slipped and accidenly voted for that lol