Rate My Supercoach Team!!! advice greatly appreciated

[AJLocandro]

Backs: Goddard, Gibbs, Birchall, Bock, Staker, Terlich. Bench:  Colquhon, Docherty
Mids: Ablett, Pendlebury, Kennedy, Cotchin, Selwood, Viney, O'Meara, Crouch.  Bench: Jones, Simpson
Rucks: Goldstein, Leuenberger. Bench: Currie, McBean
Forwards: Franklin, Cox, Bartel, Rockliff, Macaffer, Lee. Bench: Mayes, Kerridge

Cash Remaining: $8,400
Rate out of ten and suggest improvements and i will be happy to return the favour.

Cheers!

[barnsey70]

very well balanced side, my only worry would be the rucks... leunberger is only 300k but hasnt had a pre-season ever....
and based on that and only 300k worth a try... other than that 8/10

[Hmoore96]

I'd say downgrade 1 off your mid premiums to Fyfe, gaff or Mundy then upgrade bock to Broughton. Then put Staker in your forward line so you have the defence and forward link with Staker and broughton.

[Ringo]

Nice team first up - Not worth commenting on Rookies till we see tha NAB cup form.

Def: Solid - Would not be starting with Bock will be very underdone and will be surprised if he starts Round 1 even though that is aim.  Would replace with a rookie and use cash elsewhere (Thurlow, Vlaustin, Stevenson, Van Nunen an dPittard all viable options but watch in NAB cup.
Mids: Solid Prems
Rucks; Sound - Keep Berger because if things go bad early you can move cox to Ruck and replace Berger with a forward.
Fwds: Would look for an alternative to Bartel - His SC scores have been dropping each year since his heyday in 2007. Plenty of alternates available.

Downgrading Bock will give you at least another $150k to use as you see fit. even Bartell to Roughead or Ryder for extra ruck security.

Rate this team 7.5/10.  Good luck.

[gotheroos!]

cheers for helping with my team
defence: looking good, just check on bock's fitness.
mids: loving it. sure kennedy's worth that much though?
rucks: standard, fine. just check rookies.
fwds: nice. bartel is very unique. i'd wait on buddy though.

overall nice, 8.5/10

[AJLocandro]

thanks for the advice ill post my new team up in a minute how are the changes going?

[AJLocandro]

Backs: Goddard, Gibbs, Birchall, Broughton, Thurlow, Terlich. Bench:  Colquhon, Docherty
Mids: Ablett, Pendlebury, Cotchin, Selwood, Fyfe, Viney, O'Meara, Crouch.  Bench: Jones, Simpson
Rucks: Goldstein, Leuenberger. Bench: Currie, McBean
Forwards: Franklin, Cox, Bartel, Ryder, Macaffer, Staker. Bench: Lee, Kerridge

[Jay]

Nice unique choice of premiums

A few iffy rookies like Thurlow and Simpson but NAB should sort out the rookie picks

[AJLocandro]

Well fellas here is my final team for season 2013 a lot of sleepless nights were spent fiddling with this team and i think finally two days out from the season it is looking a contender for the 50k let me know what you guys think

Backs: Goddard,Gibbs,Hanley,Goodes,Terlich, Stevenson Bench: Vlaustuin, Pittard
Mids: Ablett,Swan,Pendlebury,Kennedy,Watson,Cotchin,O'Meara,Mitchell,Viney Bench: Wines,Stevens
Rucks: Maric,Currie Bench: Leuenberger,Blicavs
Forwards: Cox,Zorko,Bartel,Siposs,Kanzesis,Macaffer Bench: Rowe,Lee

[sammy123]

good team. But maybe drop a mid prem to rookie and upgrade luey to prem. 6 prem mids is probaly a bit too much. 8/10

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,74834.0.html

[bensl]

too many prem mids for me.  that is where the cash cow rookies thrive.  ditch one of watson/swan/cotchin and strengthen your other lines.  goodes at d4 & sippos at f4 are a bit weak imo.

[Bizzle17]

You have to many midfielders in your team in general. 9 on the field and 2 bench I can count. That's 11 instead of 10.

[AJLocandro]

Backs: Goddard,Gibbs,Hanley,Goodes,Terlich, Stevenson Bench: Vlaustuin, Pittard
Mids: Ablett,Swan,Pendlebury,Kennedy,Watson,,O'Meara,Mitchell,Viney Bench: Wines,Crouch
Rucks: McEvoy,Blicavs Bench: Rowe,Currie
Forwards: Franklin,Cox,Zorko,Bartel,Kanzesis,Macaffer Bench: Neade,Lee
let me know what you guys think of the updates and give my team a rate out of 10 and suggest improvemnets and any thoughts you may have and i will be more than happy to return the favour, cheers