Want every single critism anyone of you can give it!

[Unknown42]

Back: B Gibbs, D Heppell, N Grima, D Merrett, D Terlich, S Colquhoun (J Ramsay, K Mcintosh)

Mid: G Ablett, J Watson, S Thompson, R Sloane, C Judd, L Hodge, L Whitfield, O Wines (B Crouch, J O'Meara)

Ruck: S Jacobs, N Naitanui (B Grundy, D Currie)

Fwd: L Franklin, J Roughead, A Goodes, D Hille, J Stringer, M Paparone, (M Wood, M McDonough)

Cash: 35,400

[Jukes]

Since you want all criticisms...

DISLIKES
Grima (better options)
Merrett (spud)
Ramsay and McIntosh (much better back rook options)
Whitfield (too expensive)
Naitanui (injury)
Franklin (SJ is an infinitely better option)
Hille (won't play much, far behind Belly and Ryder)

Ratings
Backs: 7/10
Mids: 8.75/10 (I really do like the pics of Judd, Sloane and Hodge)
Rucks: 8.25/10
Forwards: 7.75/10
Overall: 7.75/10 in all my months of rating teams this is the worst I've seen, even for a joke team :P

As I said, I like Judd, Sloane and Hodgey.
Judd won't get tagged much at all as he's behind Murphy in the pecking order for a tag. Could go 104-108.
Sloane won't get tagged much either behind Thommo and Danger, could average well.
If Hodge can get over his injury troubles could go back to a 90s average.

[meow meow]

No Goddard. Gibbs is talked up as having more midfield time every single year but he'll play the exact same role.
Grima is injury prone.
Sauce won't improve at all and he will be a long way off the top backmen.
Terlich will be another Couch - all hype, no results.
Colq has zero JS.
Ramsay to replace Shaw or Maxwell in Collingwood's backline? No games.
McIntosh - who is this guy?

Jobe will return to his injury prone self now that he's not allowed to have superhuman strength.
2 Crow's mids isn't a great idea. Haven't even got the best Crow.
Judd is already thinking about retirement.
Hodge is an injury prone old man who won't play round 1.

Nic Nat has an injury and even if he plays round 1 he will be underdone.

Buddy has a really tough start to the year and won't be the best forward early in the season.
Goodes may be on the decline since he is what, 34?
David Hille will be lucky to play 7 games.
Stringer has no JS and probably won't even play round 1.
I like the choice of Marco but again JS?
Both benchies probably won't play more than 5 games each.

[Unknown42]

alright cheers boys,

this is my first year trying to get all the help i can!

thanks again.