Swallow and Caddy

[tbagrocks]

Josh Caddy 20 years from Geelong
$328k
2012 22 games at 63.8 (at Gold Coast)
2011  2 games at 72

David Swallow 20 years from Gold Coast
$380k
2012 12 games at 73.8
2011 21 games at 76.3

One of these guys could make good money while scoring well at while younger than Ebert last year in their third season could they be ready to hit near 100? 44 trades of course creates for strategys like picking a young bolter,

Could even be better trading to one of them after round two if the start with 90s or 100s, downgrade a prem with a high BE

[Toga]

Tempted by Swallow but I'll be going neither. Think Fyfe is a better option at 70K more expensive. ;)

[Jukes]

Tempted by Swallow but I'll be going neither. Think Fyfe is a better option at 70K more expensive. ;)

This. Swallow and Caddy should improve their averages handsomely but will be going with Fyfe, less of a risk and should average comfortably more.

[Holz]

Swallow should go 90-95 probably about 40k too expensive though. I would go Ball over him as he is cheaper and should score about the same (maybee a few points less than swallow).

cant consider Swallow when embley is 120k cheaper.

Caddy is  just a flat out no

[Adamant]

Tempted by Swallow but I'll be going neither. Think Fyfe is a better option at 70K more expensive. ;)

This. Swallow and Caddy should improve their averages handsomely but will be going with Fyfe, less of a risk and should average comfortably more.

Yep, I've got Fyfey locked in. He should be around the 105 mark, and could even become a keeper...

[blue]

i would take swallow over caddy just because i know if fit swallow will play every game, caddy im not sure on, he will get his chance but he has to establish himself in a established team. end of the day swallow will scroe higher

[hardnut]

Swallow a worthy punt if taking 2+ mid pricers in mids. Caddy a strong no from me.

[tbagrocks]

So no good news on the Caddy front gess i'll have to rule that out

I'm still looking at strategys but really, we're seen 20 year olds hit over 10 before and if Swallow is looking anything like this, maybe during the (blatent over commersialization in the nab) cup or even posts two decent scores in rounds 1-2 then a high BE premo could become Swallow, or another botler that hits two tons

[Jukes]

Tempted by Swallow but I'll be going neither. Think Fyfe is a better option at 70K more expensive. ;)

This. Swallow and Caddy should improve their averages handsomely but will be going with Fyfe, less of a risk and should average comfortably more.

Yep, I've got Fyfey locked in. He should be around the 105 mark, and could even become a keeper...

I'm thinking he's a very good chance of being 107+, and couple that with maybe a top 5 in the Brownlow if he plays every game.

Only reason I'd keep him out of my side is for structural problems, don't see that much of a chance though. Next big thing, best thing is he's a Claremont boy :D