Whaddya Think? First go for 2013

Started by Mozza84, February 06, 2013, 06:48:59 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Mozza84

Backs: Goddard, Grimes, Gibbs, Hanley, B.Goodes, Docherty - Pittard, L.Stevenson
Mids: Ablett, Tuck, K.Jack, Fyfe, Ball, Wines, Crouch, O'Meara - Viney, T.Mitchell
Rucks: Cox, Sandilands - Gorringe, Grundy
Fwds: S.Johnson, Rockliff, Robinson, A.Goodes, Daniher, Staker - Macaffer, Mayes

Whats everyone's thoughts on my first go for 2013?

LF

Goodes probably won`t play round 1 and I personally think there are better options than him this year
lose Daniher as well
Lose either Cox or Sandilands down to Luey
I`d lose Tuck and Ball from the midfield

Bring in Embley and one of either Pendles,Cotchin,Murphy,Deledio or Boyd for example
Swap Daniher ot either Knights,Sylvia,Byrnes or Varcoe a then Goodes to another premo.

thefuzz

Way too risky/unique in the mids mate
I would only have 2 of tuck, jack, fyfe, and ball (max).
and yeah you have to get leuenberger in there mate (instead of sandi I reckon)
Get rid of Goodes too mate, unless you were only planning on having him for the first 2 games then trading him out or something (which is quite  a valid strategy imo). Around his price I'd go for Martin otherwise maybe Zorko?

SydneyRox

like the backs 9/10
mids, you are a premium short, need to find room for murphy or pendles 6/10
rucks super premium, but moving cox into your fwds and bringing in luey might help 8/10
goodes is a massive risk. will play rnd 1, but might be a little underdone, and is likely to spend less time in the midfield 7/10

Windigo

Pretty sure Dogs have a spot to elevate Goodes??

They are waiting for NAB cup to decide on who to elevate.

LF

Talking about Adam Goodes Windigo not B Goodes lol

Windigo


Mozza84

Updated Team... take 2

BTW my team name is All The Goodes, I am a Swans supporter so hence the reason for always having Adam(and now Brett) in my team :-)

Backs: Goddard, Grimes, Gibbs, Bock , B.Goodes, Docherty - Pittard, Terlich
Mids: Ablett, Boyd, Cotchin, Fyfe, ROK, Wines, Crouch, O'Meara - Mayes, T.Mitchell
Rucks: Cox, Leuenberger - Gorringe, Daw
Fwds: Franklin, S.Johnson, Rockliff, A.Goodes, Varcoe, Staker - Macaffer, Lee

$22.1K left over

Thoughts & Advice?

LF

Bock is not likely to play round 1.
Your back line is slightly underdone i liked your original backline better.
I`d drop Franklin and bring Robbo back in or move Cox forward and put a link in your rucks like Rowe and bring in a cheaper ruck like Goldstein or Bellchambers or McEvoy.
Still don`t like Goodes in forwards there are much better options than him but each to there own.

Grannyboy

I liked the couple of uniques in Tuck n Jack in the mid and they get the job done. I spose Boyd n Cotch are ok too though. :) You have dpp's in the back and forward lines but only one in the middle, I'd change that for a bit of security in those early rounds. Not bad though, a few money makers a few guns, it should go ok. A.Goodes is an interesting one, I personally wouldn't start him but he does have a decent dt history. But really he should give 1 of those Brownlows to Crawf and last years cup to Hodgey.  :P