Sylvia v Lecras

[turry17]

Who do you think is the better pick out of these two? Both underpriced just can't decide who

[Jukes]

Sylvia will average a lot more, like 10 more. Unless you need that 40k, definitely go Sylvia.

[turry17]

Sylvia will average a lot more, like 10 more. Unless you need that 40k, definitely go Sylvia.

Cheers for that, the 40k might be used to squeeze in a mid pricer in my defence but could probably do without that

[Windigo]

Sylvia is 100 K cheaper than what he is capable of, been in the the rehab group, but only minor I think.  ;)

[GM]

Sylvia is 100 K cheaper than what he is capable of, been in the the rehab group, but only minor I think.  ;)

So Windi would Knights be better value at his price than Sylvia?

[Kellogscrunchynut]

Sylvia easily I can't see Lecras averaging more than 80, whereas Sylvia has in the past averaged over 90 and has a huge ceiling.

[Ricochet]

Sylvia has the ability to go 95 over the early rounds. Lecca has never been a high DT scorer. Has to be Sylvia easily imo

[Windigo]

Sylvia is 100 K cheaper than what he is capable of, been in the the rehab group, but only minor I think.  ;)

So Windi would Knights be better value at his price than Sylvia?

That's a toughie, I have both. Both are much maligned players...I'd go Sylva just because he will more than likely average 90+ and it would take a huge effort for Knights to get that or even 85+.....

Go both.  :P

[timmyparso]

Sylvia has the ability to go 95 over the early rounds. Lecca has never been a high DT scorer. Has to be Sylvia easily imo

Round 16 2010 LeCras scored 12 goals 2 with 176 DT points!!!! Food for thought  ;)

[Chelskiman]

Sylvia has the ability to go 95 over the early rounds. Lecca has never been a high DT scorer. Has to be Sylvia easily imo

Round 16 2010 LeCras scored 12 goals 2 with 176 DT points!!!! Food for thought  ;)

JRoo has also pumped out a 150 before, would you call him a high scorer?

[Windigo]

..Kyle Reimers.  ;D

Lecras 'can' go big, but how many times do you see him kicking 12 goals in a game?

[LF]

I'm going with LeCras for now pending NAB cup
I've read an article about him and Hill rotating though the midfield.
I'm really interested to see how Woosha structures the Eagles this year with all the boys who are coming back from injuries.

[Ricochet]

Sylvia has the ability to go 95 over the early rounds. Lecca has never been a high DT scorer. Has to be Sylvia easily imo

Round 16 2010 LeCras scored 12 goals 2 with 176 DT points!!!! Food for thought  ;)

haha yeh and averaged 76 for the year  :P

[Ziplock]

Sylvia destroys Lecras. Lecras has had one season with a decent average, and is coming off a serious injury. Sylvia has had multiple seasons with a premium average, and is discounted since he had no preseason last year, due to him literally breaking his back... he averaged clear over 90 after his bye from memory.

[elephants]

Despite the extended preseason of Lecca I think he will take a little bit to work his way into the season. Culd be a cheeky upgrade target as you F7 late in the year ;)