Marc.M vs Josh.P.K

[felsty]

My midfield currently consists of Ablett, Swan, Pendlebury, Cotchin and the rest rookies
Love Murphys value and what he could be capable of under Mick
Think with Kennedys draw he can at least hold his superb average this season

Please vote and comment if you can.. Thanks

[Ricochet]

Expecting both to average similar but with Marc's price i think you have to have him in. That extra 40k could be very handy

[Southstorm]

I was also facing this dilemma but in the end I went with JPK because of the bye.

[tor01doc]

Murphy doesn't face Jones until round 7 or 8 from memory so would either start or wait until after that round.

JPK for me in the vote.

[Hippo]

If you wanted Murphy an option is to start with JPK and trade him too Smurph before rd3 or 4.

this way you get JPK predicted kick ass scores against rabble but end up with who you wanted in Murphy - yeah burns a trade but this game is about pts.

Doing this you can use the Loophole C with JPK against GC and GWS and potentially be up 80-100pts on the rest of the field

[quinny88]

That's an expensive starting mid. I would drop one of swan or pendles and get both of murph and kennedy

[Capper]

JPK is more a DT player, if you are looking for a Swan, go with Jack or ROK for SC

[Ricochet]

JPK is more a DT player, if you are looking for a Swan, go with Jack or ROK for SC

??? Kennedy averages like 20 more points in SC and a top 6 mid... in DT he's like top 20

[SydneyRox]

JPK is more a DT player, if you are looking for a Swan, go with Jack or ROK for SC

Not sure I agree with that statement?? JPK had almost a 20 point differential last year and 10 in 2011.

I would also agree if you are set on the current guys, pick Murphy the $40k will help elsewhere. But if you are not set, I would swap Cotchin for JPK and get Murphy

[Sabretooth Tigers]

Hippo + 1,

[upthemaidens]

JPK is more a DT player, if you are looking for a Swan, go with Jack or ROK for SC

If anything Kennedy is a SC player,, wouldnt touch him in DT

[tbagrocks]

Troll ;D Nice one tabs ;)

Haha if ever their was a player you would struggle to put in your DT but lockity lock lock in your SC it's Josh Kennedy :P

Where's the Mexican girl :P i'll most likely be having both but JPK is very expensive :'(

[Peter]

Have both at moment. Why - Cotchin will hold value and can be picked up anytime and imo Swan will drop, so upgrade target

[Capper]

Sure he scored well last year in SC but in previous years he was a much better DT player than SC player.

Dont pick Jack, leave him for me  ;D

[Hippo]

JPK 2012

Ranked first for clearances and contested possessions, second in hard-ball gets and equal fourth for centre clearances,

If thats not a SC player Tabs then i am the Pope