Ask Ziplock Pre-season

[Ziplock]

Just wanting your opinion on Stevens (esp. with Boydos out) vs Whitfield.

ehhh... tbh, I think they'll average pretty similar. That being said, stevens larger body means he'll be able to handle the rigours of AFL a bit better than whitfield, and he probs wont get subbed either.

[Ziplock]

Zip continuing Stews question, how close will those 2 score to Maloney. Fair bit of money to be spent elsewhere if you think they would be close - cheers mate

I'm backing moloney in for a 90+ average atm, compared to stevens/ whitfield who'll probably top out around 80 odd.

[Dudge]

Zip continuing Stews question, how close will those 2 score to Maloney. Fair bit of money to be spent elsewhere if you think they would be close - cheers mate

I'm backing moloney in for a 90+ average atm, compared to stevens/ whitfield who'll probably top out around 80 odd.

Fair enough Zip but would the price rise be worth the loss of 10+ points early?

[Ziplock]

Zip continuing Stews question, how close will those 2 score to Maloney. Fair bit of money to be spent elsewhere if you think they would be close - cheers mate

I'm backing moloney in for a 90+ average atm, compared to stevens/ whitfield who'll probably top out around 80 odd.

Fair enough Zip but would the price rise be worth the loss of 10+ points early?

atm I have moloney, my reasoning being that I can draw a lot of parallels between him and tuck- I think he's worth at least a 90 avg, but could easily go up to 100. 

[essendon2]

Moloney + Blicavs (r2) + Martin
vs
K.Mitchell + Longer + Chapman


Do you think Mitchell will be the sub? :-\

[Ziplock]

Moloney 90 + Blicavs (r2) 60 + Martin (dustin?) 90= 240
vs
K.Mitchell 80 + Longer 70 + Chapman 95= 245


Do you think Mitchell will be the sub? :-\

pretty much an even split. Option 1 for me though.

I don't think mitchell will be subbed- a large part of his game is his elite endurance, I think as a sub that he'd be wasted.

[Adamant]

Jelwood or Murphy, Zip?

[Ricochet]

Chappy v Bartel

[Ziplock]

Jelwood or Murphy, Zip?

Jelwood

[Ziplock]

Chappy v Bartel

chapman

[Ricochet]

Chappy v Bartel

chapman

and your reasoning man?

[Adamant]

Yeah, reasoning please Zip? :)

[elephants]

Bloody hell, demanding lot you boys :P

[Ziplock]

Jelwood or Murphy, Zip?

Jelwood

I've been losing a lot of confidence in murphy recently with his tagibility, especially with judd declining so much. I rate jelwood asa more consistent option, with a better chance of going around 108+.

[Ziplock]

Chappy v Bartel

chapman

I've gone chapman basically because of bartels scoring pattern- since 2007 his scores have decreased every year. Both have proved to score 110+, bartel may be more durable (in recent years it's been about the same), but chapman has been showing less of a slide.