Ask Ziplock Pre-season

[Noz]

If your going for overall can you afford to get Embley at M5 alongside 4 premiums and 3 rookies on field? or will the 5 premiums 3 rookies be the better option.

[Ziplock]

Hey Zip..

Sylvia & Mayes vs Varcoe & Morton ?

Sylvia + Mayes: you get a keeper in sylvia, as opposed to morton/ varcoe.

that being said, macaffer/ staker > mayes.

[Ziplock]

If your going for overall can you afford to get Embley at M5 alongside 4 premiums and 3 rookies on field? or will the 5 premiums 3 rookies be the better option.

I think you can- you obv. wouldn't just have embley though, or your salary cap wouldn't be used. It's more like

embley + ball+ (wines, whitfield etc.) vs premium + rookie + rookie

I think it's viable personally. Those two will average 90 each, just outscoring a premium + basement rookie, are less prone to the vest than a rookie and the extra cash will be useful.

[Noz]

Right now i had

Embley (M5) + Franklin (F1) + Johnson (F2)
V
Kennedy (M4) + Rioli (F4), Sylvia (F5)

[Ziplock]

Right now i had

Embley (M5) + Franklin (F1) + Johnson (F2)
V
Kennedy (M4) + Rioli (F4), Sylvia (F5)

I feel like the second one is too risky :/

[Artax]

Hey Zip..

Sylvia & Mayes vs Varcoe & Morton ?

Sylvia + Mayes: you get a keeper in sylvia, as opposed to morton/ varcoe.

that being said, macaffer/ staker > mayes.

Also have Mac.. Staker is in the backs

[Ziplock]

you might be able to do without staker in the backs if you substitute him for like pittard/ stevenson/ goodes/ docherty

[Money]

Right now I have 5 mid premos, I was thinking if downgrading one and upgrading somehwere else, but with only 4 premos will that leave me too far behind the rest...???

[Tominator]

Brett Goodes or Brett Staker ?

Gary Ablett or Scott Pendlebury + extra cash ?

Brent Macaffer or Tom Lee ?

Trent Cotchin or Brent Stanton ?



Thanks so much Zippyyyy

[Ziplock]

Right now I have 5 mid premos, I was thinking if downgrading one and upgrading somehwere else, but with only 4 premos will that leave me too far behind the rest...???

no, you'll be fine so long as you fully utilise your cash.

[Ziplock]

1.Brett Goodes or Brett Staker ?

2.Gary Ablett or Scott Pendlebury + extra cash ?

3.Brent Macaffer or Tom Lee ?

4.Trent Cotchin or Brent Stanton ?



Thanks so much Zippyyyy

1. Staker. Doesnt need to be upgraded, proven scorer etc.
2. If you have swan, then pendles, providing you use the cash elsewhere. If ablett is  M1, then ablett.
3. Macaffer if you have the cash.
4. Neither. Seriously. If you have to choose between them, stanton has more upside. But seriously, neither.

[Tominator]

1.Brett Goodes or Brett Staker ?

2.Gary Ablett or Scott Pendlebury + extra cash ?

3.Brent Macaffer or Tom Lee ?

4.Trent Cotchin or Brent Stanton ?



Thanks so much Zippyyyy

1. Staker. Doesnt need to be upgraded, proven scorer etc.
2. If you have swan, then pendles, providing you use the cash elsewhere. If ablett is  M1, then ablett.
3. Macaffer if you have the cash.
4. Neither. Seriously. If you have to choose between them, stanton has more upside. But seriously, neither.

thanks a heap mate... but I've got Swan as M1... should I grab Ablett and Pendles then ? Instead of Stanton/Cotch

[Artax]

Why no love for Cotch?

[Ziplock]

1.Brett Goodes or Brett Staker ?

2.Gary Ablett or Scott Pendlebury + extra cash ?

3.Brent Macaffer or Tom Lee ?

4.Trent Cotchin or Brent Stanton ?



Thanks so much Zippyyyy

1. Staker. Doesnt need to be upgraded, proven scorer etc.
2. If you have swan, then pendles, providing you use the cash elsewhere. If ablett is  M1, then ablett.
3. Macaffer if you have the cash.
4. Neither. Seriously. If you have to choose between them, stanton has more upside. But seriously, neither.

thanks a heap mate... but I've got Swan as M1... should I grab Ablett and Pendles then ? Instead of Stanton/Cotch

yep, ablett + pendles destroys stanton + cotch.

[Chelskiman]

Hey, Zip!

Just another "vs" scenario. 

Maric + Sylvia v Goldstein + Robinson?