Kennedy v Dangerfield v Cotchin

[tbagrocks]

I want one of these three to start  but have a feeling JPK will be the one to hold his ave early

Josh Kennedy 24yrs
$643,000
Ave 120.2
High scores: 168, 173, 157, 127, 126, 132, 122, 139, 18 tons from 22 games + 132 and 147 in finals

Patrick Dangerfield 22yrs
$636,000
Ave: 118.9
High scores: 174, 187, 169, 141, 145, 138, 134, 133, 127, 122, 13 tons 22 games including 8 from last 8 with a low of 110, and nothing below 86 during season

Trent Cotchin 22yrs
$622,100
Ave: 116.3
High scores: 175, 141, 136, 130, 127, 126, 123, 122, 123, 124, 19 tons 22 games one low of 73 next 98

[masedog333]

the cotchininator

[tbagrocks]

Why are people voting Cotchin when his scores were clearly lower, is it because he's the cheaper?

[TheAnt]

Cotchins consistency was better then Dangerfield and his ceiling is just as high, that's why.

[MTTY]

Kennedy for me Tbag, saw him a lot last year and he is pure SC gold just by the way he plays. All three play very similar but i see Kennedy as being of greater consistency and higher ceiling.

[Frankfaust1]

LOve all 3 of these guys, but Kennedy is the only one in at the mo.

[kilbluff1985]

yeah love all 3 but voted Dangerfield looks like he will spend time up forward and less time on the bench

[tbagrocks]

I really thought this would get more discussion, well there's some nice stats for people so i'll bump it ;D

[quinny88]

13 tons for danger and 19 for cotch is a good indicator as to why people are going with him. Consistency

[tbagrocks]

13 tons for danger and 19 for cotch is a good indicator as to why people are going with him. Consistency

Yeah fair enough but ... it's not a two horse race


I actually agree with this

Kennedy for me Tbag, saw him a lot last year and he is pure SC gold just by the way he plays. All three play very similar but i see Kennedy as being of greater consistency and higher ceiling.

This guy was as good as anyone, played 22 games at 120

[quinny88]

13 tons for danger and 19 for cotch is a good indicator as to why people are going with him. Consistency

Yeah fair enough but ... it's not a two horse race


I actually agree with this

Kennedy for me Tbag, saw him a lot last year and he is pure SC gold just by the way he plays. All three play very similar but i see Kennedy as being of greater consistency and higher ceiling.

This guy was as good as anyone, played 22 games at 120

Yeah absolutely, Kennedy a solid choice also

[tbagrocks]

Really strange, people voting Cotch but no comments as to why? I'd be willing to bet money JPK will beat him but there's not much of a reason to pick Cotch in this thread, maybe state why when you vote? ???

What's the bet Danger and JPK both finish with a higher ave? Com'on i'll take a bet? All these votes but why is Cotch a better player to start with?

[meow meow]

Really strange, people voting Cotch but no comments as to why? I'd be willing to bet money JPK will beat him but there's not much of a reason to pick Cotch in this thread, maybe state why when you vote? ???

What's the bet Danger and JPK both finish with a higher ave? Com'on i'll take a bet? All these votes but why is Cotch a better player to start with?

It's because Richmond supporters do their best work during preseason. They hype themselves up like no other team can. All their players are going to be absolute superstars and they will definitely make finals this year. This is their year.

Round 1 rolls around and they lose to Carlton and literally cry about it. Then they realise that they're not making finals and will probably finish 9th so they disappear until next preseason.

Then repeat.

[Jay]

Kennedy for me tbag - like MTTY said, pure SC gun

[SydneyRox]

Kennedy for me tbag - like MTTY said, pure SC gun

+1

all three are solid, but JPKwill finish the year on top