After 15 Attempts, please rate my Supercoach Team

[usylum]

**I have only listed my starting line-up**

DEFENDERS:

GODDARD, Brendon
GIBBS, Bryce
MORRIS, Steven
TALIA, Daniel
PLOWMAN, Lachlan
GOODES, Brett [MID]

MIDFIELDERS:

PENDLEBURY, Scott
WATSON, Jobe
KENNEDY, Josh P.
SELWOOD, Joel
COTCHIN, Trent
THOMPSON, Scott
SWALLOW, Andrew
WHITFIELD, Lachie

RUCKS:
GOLDSTEIN, Todd
MUMFORD, Shane

FORWARDS:

JOHNSON, Steve [MID]
KRAKOUER, Andrew
VARCOE, Travis [MID]
KNIGHTS, Chris
DANIHER, Joe
MACAFFER, Brent


Cheers,
Beau

[grimes2015]

Forward look a bit thin. Need to downgrade a prem mid and get Rocky, Buddy, Martin in there.
Defence looks weak too. Morris and Talia must go, plowman too expensive for a rookie too.
Rucks good.
Mids too good ;)

[johnnytheboy1]

First i would like to say that you have far too many premiums and your cash cow is an expensive.
To get a good balance side you only need 4-5 premium mids.
So I would downgrade Swallow & Thompson to Rookies e.g O''meara,Wines,Viney
Get Rid of Talia & Morris better of with Birchall & Yarran. Iwould also replace plowman with Docherty.
I think you should have Luenberger as   Second Ruck to free up money to improve your forward line which needs another 2 premiums

I give your team a 5/10 because it is unbalanced.

[usylum]

**UPDATED**

Changes in BOLD

DEFENDERS:

GODDARD, Brendon
GIBBS, Bryce
BIRCHALL, Grant
YARRAN, Chris
TERLICH, Dean
GOODES, Brett [MID]

MIDFIELDERS:

PENDLEBURY, Scott
WATSON, Jobe
KENNEDY, Josh P.
SELWOOD, Joel
COTCHIN, Trent
THOMPSON, Scott
JONES, Matt (got O'Meara & Viney - as SUBS)
WHITFIELD, Lachie

RUCKS:

GOLDSTEIN, Todd
MUMFORD, Shane

FORWARDS:

JOHNSON, Steve [MID]
KRAKOUER, Andrew
VARCOE, Travis [MID]
KNIGHTS, Chris
MARTIN, Dustin
MACAFFER, Brent