Grimes VS Heppell

[ADEZ]

This selection has been killing me, I think Grimes will go 97 and Heppell will average 91
Logically I should go Grimes but with Heppell in his third year and already showing such consistency and durability whereas Grimes not so much...
Plus the spare cash will be very handy

[Windigo]

Hepp D has massive potential after two years of roughly the same average, surely the only way is up?

- I don't like giving predicted scores, don't think it is completely necessary.  :P

[stew42]

Both will score well, but due to durability, I'm going with Hep D

[Jukes]

I reckon they'll both average about 94, I'd give the nod to Heppell due to a lower price and better durability, in addition to the promise of mroe midfield time.

http://www.news.com.au/sport/afl/essendon-young-gun-dyson-heppell-looking-to-influence-play-further-up-the-ground/story-fnelctok-1226548524216
http://www.sportsnewsfirst.com.au/articles/2012/01/27/watson-tips-heppell-switch-to-midfield/

[ADEZ]

Hepp D has massive potential after two years of roughly the same average, surely the only way is up?

- I don't like giving predicted scores, don't think it is completely necessary.  :P

Cheers for the responses

and yeah, votes were rendered useless as I forgot to tick two options, locked the poll now
::)

[Windigo]

Haha, I was just about to comment regarding that over sight.  :P

[hardnut]

I think there is good reason too take both as they should comfortably be in top 10 defenders and probably top 6. Saves the headaches associated with picking the Broughton/Duffield/Hartlett types

[Football Factory]

Grimes barring injury will average more comfortably imo

[kilbluff1985]

see no reason not to have both

[Jukes]

see no reason not to have both

Because Grimes doesn't fit my structure personally. Only fitting 4 premos in my backline absolute max, and not dropping Goddard, Gibbs or Lake.

[tbagrocks]

yeah pick Lake over Grimes that'll end well ::)

I want both but also want a Duff so a little dilema at the Rocks, Grimes fit will ave more I agree, he's older and hitting his prime as a midfielder

[kilbluff1985]

yeah pick Lake over Grimes that'll end well ::)

I want both but also want a Duff so a little dilema at the Rocks, Grimes fit will ave more I agree, he's older and hitting his prime as a midfielder

lol yeah going Lake over Heppell/Grimes is amusing

[Football Factory]

yeah pick Lake over Grimes that'll end well ::)

I want both but also want a Duff so a little dilema at the Rocks, Grimes fit will ave more I agree, he's older and hitting his prime as a midfielder

lol yeah going Lake over Heppell/Grimes is amusing

:o

[Jukes]

Lake will average 2-3 points less than Grimes for 80k less. Obvious choice for me.

[Presto]

see no reason not to have both

Because Grimes doesn't fit my structure personally. Only fitting 4 premos in my backline absolute max, and not dropping Goddard, Gibbs or Lake.

::)
Picking Lake over either Grimes or Heppell makes absolute sense if you take advise from a 4yo girl.