World Tominaton - Tominator's DT Pre-Season 2013

[Tominator]

No that is not my name, but I was just wondering if people could come to this thread; keep an eye on it, and give me feedback for my team when I post it (multiple times as there will be constant changes made)

Apologies for not revealing my gun unique pick though, but this guy is a gem and he is a secret find   ;)

Thanks a lot   :)




To get the ball rolling, here is my first team.... thoughts?

________________________________________________________________________________________________


REMAINING SALARY CAP - $700

DEFENCE
Brendon Goddard, Bryce Gibbs, Hamish Hartlett, Nathan Bock, Nick Vlastuin, Dean Terlich

Bench: Sam Colquhoun, Sam Docherty

MIDFIELD
Dane Swan, Scott Pendlebury, Trent Cotchin, Brent Stanton, Nathan Fyfe, Jack Viney, Jaeger O'Meara, Oliver Wines

Bench: *MIDFIELD SMOKIE*, Brad Crouch

RUCK
Hamish McIntosh, Matthew Leuenberger

Bench: Sam Rowe, Brodie Grundy

FORWARD
Lance Franklin, Steve Johnson, Tom Rockliff, Luke Breust, Chris Knights, Robbie Gray

Bench: Joe Daniher, Troy Menzel

[Jukes]

We've been chatting on chat about our teams for ages, I'mma going to just do suggested alterations and ratings, mate.

Suggestions
Buddy -> Stevie J!!!
Gray -> Byrnes (Gray under an enormous injury cloud, looks like to miss NAB cup and maybe even a few early matches)
Daniher or Menzel -> Lee

Ratings (I'll try and keep them as unbias as possible mate)
Backs: 8/10
Mids: 8.5/10
Rucks: 8/10, I guess
Forwards: 9.15/10
Overall: 8.35/10

[Tominator]

We've been chatting on chat about our teams for ages, I'mma going to just do suggested alterations and ratings, mate.

Suggestions
Buddy -> Stevie J!!!
Gray -> Byrnes (Gray under an enormous injury cloud, looks like to miss NAB cup and maybe even a few early matches)
Daniher or Menzel -> Lee

Ratings (I'll try and keep them as unbias as possible mate)
Backs: 8/10
Mids: 8.5/10
Rucks: 8/10, I guess
Forwards: 9.15/10
Overall: 8.35/10

I've updated it, wanna do that again? haha

I have Stanton now....

[Jukes]

Mids: 10/10 now ;)

Probably won't change that much,

Overall: 8.4/10

[Tominator]

Mids: 10/10 now ;)

Probably won't change that much,

Overall: 8.4/10

good lad

cheers mate



all other observations most welcome   :)

[kilbluff1985]

get rid of Stanton

[Jukes]

get rid of Stanton

boooooooo gtfo :P

[Tominator]

Troy Menzel to Brent Macaffer?

THEN... Hamish Hartlett to Matt Suckling?

[kilbluff1985]

Troy Menzel to Brent Macaffer?

THEN... Stanton to Greene

[Windigo]

Troy Menzel to Brent Macaffer?

THEN... Hamish Hartlett to Matt Suckling?

Not Suckling!  :o

[Master Q]

Scrap the whole backline other than Goddard and Gibbs  :P

[Tominator]

Troy Menzel to Brent Macaffer?

THEN... Hamish Hartlett to Matt Suckling?

Not Suckling!  :o

but Menzel to Maccaffer yes?

Scrap the whole backline other than Goddard and Gibbs  :P

yeah backline is my weak link ahaha... any suggestions Q?

[SydneyRox]

You need another premium in your backs, a grimes/heppell/shaw. Keep one of Hartlett or Bock, both is too much.
Stanton is a calculated risk, every reason he could come out and smash it like he did last year, so I dont mind that one.
Hmac worries me, would much rather see a premium ruck in there.
In the fwds you have picked guys with no consistency, thought you were moving Gray to Byrnes?
I would also move Franklin to Cox if you cant afford to upgrade Hmac.
Not a bad start 7/10

[Tominator]

thoughts on Luke Ball ? 343K could be a steal for him

[kilbluff1985]

thoughts on Luke Ball ? 343K could be a steal for him

rather Embley