Quick rate anybody?

[Dylbags]

Goddard, Duffield, Hartlett, Broughton, Goodes, Pittard
Docherty, Turlich

Ablett, Swan, Cotchin, Selwood, Whitfield, Toumpas, Wines, K.Mitchell
Omeara, Viney

Cox, Leuey
Grundy, Currie

Franklin, Walker, Rockliff, Lecras, Varcoe, Mcaffer
Staker, Lee

$174,000 very rough draft, few peoples thoughts please!

[lozza63]

Hey Dylbags.

I quite like this side.
Just a few tweaks.
Drop Broughton for a rookie eg Colquhoun type and use the excess cash to slot in another mid premium rather than Whitfield. Think Gibbs looks quite good value and should be included - he could just about top the averages this year. Hartlett i really like as a pick too. Dicey with injury history still with 30 trades should be ok.

Just on Whitfield - he doesnt look ready for the rigors of AFL to me. Toumpas is a little query fitness wise, job security looks great.
Like the rucks although think another R/F is neede in case Leuy breaks down - free insurance so to speak. Those rucks are bound to score the ton avg so wont hurt to have another in there.

Varcoe - think he'll break out? Maybe - i would like a rookie compared to him. Lecras, he really needs midfield time - just dont think he's that much of a bargain.

[Jay]

B: Flawless apart from the spelling of Terlich ;) Like the premium choices - who knows what Broughts will do but at that price its worth a shot.

M: Perfect premium choices - good to see Selwood getting some love, seems to be a unique :o Expensive mid rookies, I would look at downgrading Toumpas to Crouch

R: Great line - Cox should start off very well with no NicNat. Good rookie choices too, should get games at some stage.

F: Like the picks of Walker and Rockliff - Wouldnt go both of Lecras and Varcoe, one would be enough. I'd prefer JJK over both anyway.

Good team with some more cash to splash. 8/10

[big_cox21]

cox to forwards for tex and then pick up a mummy jacobs or goldy in the rucks.

also duffield hartlett and broughts, one needs to be birchall or gibbs. both very very reliable.

after all that you should still have a bucket load of cash. go toumpas to croucha and witfield to whatever you can get. ball chould be in range or downgrade broughts/hartlett and then get a another super premo. if you want cash on your bench to start with i wouldnt go much more then 50k

hope you consider this good advice :)

[Dylbags]

Thanks a heap for the feedback guys! Will get to your teams if youve posted them!

[mabo]

Don't forget, Brett Goodes hasn't been promoted from the rookie list.

http://www.westernbulldogs.com.au/team/players/rookie

[big_cox21]

Thanks a heap for the feedback guys! Will get to your teams if youve posted them!

http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,71036.0.html

would really appreciate your thoughts and a rate of ten :)

btw i give yours a 7/10. lost a few point because of your weak midfield.