First time request!

[Artax]

Long time poster on FF but have never asked to have a team rated so why not?!

BACKS
Goddard Gibbs Heppell Broughton Birchall Plowman (Terlich/Van Unen)

MIDS
Swan GARY Cotchin Watson Ball Embley Omeara Crouch (Viney/Hrovat)

RUCKS
Cox Luey (Witts/Currie)

FORWARDS
Franklin Rocky Knights Varcoe Macaffer Morton (Dick/Lee)

Thinkng 1 back downgrade & 1 forward upgrade?

Any other suggestions?

[gricho20]

B) I have heard Plowman is overpriced and doesn't really have JS. Never heard of Van Unen.

M) Love the 4 Super-Gun mids. I really like Port's rookies though, Wines+K.Mitch.

R) Safe. I'm starting Cox forward as a safety net and going Goldy/Burger who will add cash with a possibility of being keepers. I think Grundy will play for pies before Witts (same price). Haven't heard much on Currie but I had a snoop around on Daw and I think he's been North's solo #1 VFL ruckman for 2 years and he is a ripped unit. Suspended indefinitely early last season for lying to Scott so hopefully he's served his time- NAB will show.

F) Buddy has a rough early draw so should drop in price. Caff, Morton and Dick all depend on NAB and Rd1 teams.

[Artax]

Cheers mate. Am on the same page re: the rucks. Swapped Grundy for Witts as I heard Grundy is injured? Currie is a former Swan who dominated at SANFL level last year. That spot will go to whoever looks more likely to play between him and Daw..

Hopefully it is Daw as I've named the team "Majak - The Gathering"

[Mr.Craig]

Nothing bad to say about the mids and rucks - all good.

You should definitely move some money from the backs to the forwards. With Pittard, Staker, Stevenson, Docherty, Vlastuin, Goodes, Thurlow and Colquhoun all having varying potential to play Round 1 there's no reason to go so strong in the backs. I think you should downgrade Birchall and turn one of Morton/Macaffer/Dick into a premium.

[Artax]

Thanks man, am wondering if Lake will impact Birchall's scoring at all. Birch has always been so good to me!

[Jukes]

Likes
Neat midfield
Strong backline
Van Unen is a unique rookie selection, reckon he's a very decent chance of playing a fair few games
Mitch Morton

Dislikes
I reckon there's better options that Plowman as gricho stated. For 40k less you can have others such as Stevenson, Docherty, Colq who have similar JS and probably higher scoring potential.
Brad Dick- rate him as next to no chance of getting a game, Mayes or Menzel should defs go in if you have the cash
Franklin; Stevie J will average more than him by like 5 points and is cheaper.

Suggestions
Plowman -> Stevenson/Docherty/Colq
Dick -> Mayes/Menzel (whichever is better priced in your opinion)
Franklin -> Stevie J

Ratings
Backs: 9/10
Mids: 9.25/10
Rucks: 8/10
Forwards: 7/10
Overall: 8.35/10 good team anchored by two great lines, would definitely look to upgrade your forward line ASAP when the season kicks off and your rooks/mid-pricers start to rise in price.

[Artax]

Thanks Jukes, sound advice as always!

[Jukes]

Thanks Jukes, sound advice as always!

aha you're to kind :3