Jelwood or Murphy

[hawkers65]

Before Today i had Mundy but i had a spare 150k so i was able to make this trade. Worried about his ankle reoccurring again. IMO both can go 120+ this year. Who would you pick?

[batt]

Still waiting to see Murph consistently breaking a tag.  As a round 1 pick I'd probably go with Jelwood because he's much less likely to have a handsome price dip.

[quinny88]

I think Murphy is underpriced so I would say him but Selwood also a solid pick

[blue]

i think the key here is murphy m5, sellwood m4. i think there both on par. I would take murphy before sellwood as i expect the blues to have a better year,

[jabroni]

i feel selwood is the better SC player but beware his tendency to go in hard and get injured/suspended

[kilbluff1985]

Murphy

[Adamant]

Murphy is seriously underpriced and I would be leaning towards him.

Jelwood is a very good option and always starts the year on fire though.

[Jay]

Selwood for me. Murph has not shown he can consistently break a tag.

[nrich102]

Id go Murphy.

[kfewster]

I'd go Murphy too.

With Micky's more direct game plan and Gibbs spending more time in the middle this year will he, hopefully it will give Murphy more of  a chop out.

I'm expecting his average to increase to around 120-125 odd.

With a price of $602,900 - his approx b/e is around 111, so he is not all that underpriced.

[Diesels Pups]

Always been a toss up for me between Selwood and Murphy the last couple of years. I going Murphy this year, Selwood a bit head bang injury prone.

[SydneyRox]

I think Murphy is underpriced so I would say him but Selwood also a solid pick

+1 no doubt underpriced

[nrich102]

I think Murphy is underpriced so I would say him but Selwood also a solid pick

+1 no doubt underpriced

+2, heaps underprice

[blue]

I'd go Murphy too.

With Micky's more direct game plan and Gibbs spending more time in the middle this year will he, hopefully it will give Murphy more of  a chop out.

I'm expecting his average to increase to around 120-125 odd.

With a price of $602,900 - his approx b/e is around 111, so he is not all that underpriced.

[blue]

I'd go Murphy too.

With Micky's more direct game plan and Gibbs spending more time in the middle this year will he, hopefully it will give Murphy more of  a chop out.

I'm expecting his average to increase to around 120-125 odd.

With a price of $602,900 - his approx b/e is around 111, so he is not all that underpriced.

i dont watch a lot of collingwood games, because i cant stand the staines, but i thought under malthouse the pies played a lot of indirect footy with high possesion, which would be great for murphys sc. someone please tell me if im wrong