Appreciate some adive from you guns- updated

[melon101]

Defenders- Goddard, Gibbs, Grimes/Duffield, Broughton, Thurlow, Stevenson
(Terlich, Docherty)

Midfielders- Swan, Ablett, Pendlebury, Murphy, Embley, Wines, Lonergan, K.Mitchell
(O'mera, Viney)

Rucks- Mcintosh, Leuenberger
(Grundy, Currie)

Forwards- Johnson, Cox, Rockliff, Martin, Knights, Lee
(Staker, Mcaffer)

Cash Left- $118,100

undecided on grimes or duffman

[Capper]

HMAC at R1 is a massive call, could be the pick up of the year though. Very surprised he doesn't have DP though.

[melon101]

Yes I will be keeping a solid eye on him, if he isnt right for RD1 I may look at Bellchambers, Goldy or even Warnock if fit but for now Hmac it is

[Jukes]

I definitely reckon you should use that left over $$$ to upgrade Staker and Macaffer to Menzel and Mayes, can't see Staker or Macaffer playing over 10 games between them, while Mayes and Menzel should play 15+ games each. And that's only for 24k.

I reckon go Duffield then maybe instead of going Staker to Mayes go Staker to Byrnes.

[melon101]

You think they wont get games due to injury or not being able to get a spot in the side?

[Jukes]

You think they wont get games due to injury or not being able to get a spot in the side?

Both. They should start injury-free, but both are injury prone. Staker has seasons of 14, 6, 22, 7 and 0 in his last five seasons, while Macaffer has had 3, 17, 4 and 0 in his last four seasons, so clearly both are injury prone. Brisbane has a lot of good youngsters so Staker is likely to not be in their best 25, maybe not even best 30 players, while Macaffer will need a lot of injuries and drug-related suspensions at Collingwood to get a consistent gig.

[melon101]

These are good points and will take into consideration but i'l probably wait for the nab cup to determine those players

[tbagrocks]

I wouldn't swap a possibly injury prone rookie priced senior to a rookie with worse knees than his brother :o

[Jukes]

I wouldn't swap a possibly injury prone rookie priced senior to a rookie with worse knees than his brother :o

Menzel will actually play when fit though, he's certainly in their best 21.

[melon101]

I wouldn't swap a possibly injury prone rookie priced senior to a rookie with worse knees than his brother :o

Got a point there

[melon101]

I definitely reckon you should use that left over $$$ to upgrade Staker and Macaffer to Menzel and Mayes, can't see Staker or Macaffer playing over 10 games between them, while Mayes and Menzel should play 15+ games each. And that's only for 24k.

I reckon go Duffield then maybe instead of going Staker to Mayes go Staker to Byrnes.

Do you think I should cut down on swan to get some cash but then I may be missing out on BIG points?

[Jukes]

I definitely reckon you should use that left over $$$ to upgrade Staker and Macaffer to Menzel and Mayes, can't see Staker or Macaffer playing over 10 games between them, while Mayes and Menzel should play 15+ games each. And that's only for 24k.

I reckon go Duffield then maybe instead of going Staker to Mayes go Staker to Byrnes.

Do you think I should cut down on swan to get some cash but then I may be missing out on BIG points?

not if you don't want to/don't really need that money.

[melon101]

I definitely reckon you should use that left over $$$ to upgrade Staker and Macaffer to Menzel and Mayes, can't see Staker or Macaffer playing over 10 games between them, while Mayes and Menzel should play 15+ games each. And that's only for 24k.

I reckon go Duffield then maybe instead of going Staker to Mayes go Staker to Byrnes.

Do you think I should cut down on swan to get some cash but then I may be missing out on BIG points?

not if you don't want to/don't really need that money.

Alrighty cause ever since i went from 3 Premo back and 5 premo mid to Both 4 premo i thought I might be at a disadvatage

[Jukes]

I definitely reckon you should use that left over $$$ to upgrade Staker and Macaffer to Menzel and Mayes, can't see Staker or Macaffer playing over 10 games between them, while Mayes and Menzel should play 15+ games each. And that's only for 24k.

I reckon go Duffield then maybe instead of going Staker to Mayes go Staker to Byrnes.

Do you think I should cut down on swan to get some cash but then I may be missing out on BIG points?

not if you don't want to/don't really need that money.

Alrighty cause ever since i went from 3 Premo back and 5 premo mid to Both 4 premo i thought I might be at a disadvatage

Go with whatever you think will generate more points.

[melon101]

Just one update so far

Mcaffer ---> Byrnes