Which gun mids?

Started by hally25547, January 29, 2013, 03:06:33 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Select 2

Cotchin
29 (483.3%)
Pendlebury
44 (733.3%)
Redden
16 (266.7%)
Stanton
6 (100%)

Total Members Voted: 6

hally25547

Looking to lock in two out of the above players. I currently have Pendles and Cotch but I think Stanton could go massive this year as could Redden.

Who should I lock in?

Adamant

Pendles has to be a lock in most sides, he would be my first choice by a mile.

Then it is a toss up between Cotchin and Redden.

I prefer Redden, only because he has had two years in a row of 100+ averages. Cotchin could go backwards or average 115+, but I would go Redden for safety.

Pendles & Redden for me.

Nails

Quote from: Adamant on January 29, 2013, 03:12:52 AM
Pendles has to be a lock in most sides, he would be my first choice by a mile.

Then it is a toss up between Cotchin and Redden.

I prefer Redden, only because he has had two years in a row of 100+ averages. Cotchin could go backwards or average 115+, but I would go Redden for safety.

Pendles & Redden for me.

This guy knows what he's talking about, voted the same.

Grazz

Quote from: Nails on January 29, 2013, 03:14:12 AM
Quote from: Adamant on January 29, 2013, 03:12:52 AM
Pendles has to be a lock in most sides, he would be my first choice by a mile.

Then it is a toss up between Cotchin and Redden.

I prefer Redden, only because he has had two years in a row of 100+ averages. Cotchin could go backwards or average 115+, but I would go Redden for safety.

Pendles & Redden for me.

+1 took the words out of my mouth Ada.  :-X

This guy knows what he's talking about, voted the same.

Jukes


Toga

Pendles locked for me, is clearly the pick of that bunch.

Cotch & Redden should ave very similar this year imo so just comes down to personal preference. Atm I have cotch in at M4 as I have complete faith in him and as captain feel as though he should definitely lift his average this year.

hally25547

Ok so Pendles is locked and Stanton is no chance.

Still can't decide between Cotchin and Redden, but I am still leaning towards Cotchin because he can break a tag, goes forward when resting and is rarely out of a game for too long.

GM

Quote from: Adamant on January 29, 2013, 03:12:52 AM
Pendles has to be a lock in most sides, he would be my first choice by a mile.

Then it is a toss up between Cotchin and Redden.

I prefer Redden, only because he has had two years in a row of 100+ averages. Cotchin could go backwards or average 115+, but I would go Redden for safety.

Pendles & Redden for me.
+1.As much attention Cotchy received last year imo it will only intensify.But he will still be a top 8 mid.Red will imo have his best year,a terrific tackler and a year older,at his price he will start in my side.Moloneys inclusion will help his run and carry
outside game.

Bak2Form


henry

Quote from: Adamant on January 29, 2013, 03:12:52 AM
Pendles has to be a lock in most sides, he would be my first choice by a mile.

Then it is a toss up between Cotchin and Redden.

I prefer Redden, only because he has had two years in a row of 100+ averages. Cotchin could go backwards or average 115+, but I would go Redden for safety.

Pendles & Redden for me.
Very hard to see Cotch going backwards for me, in the back half of last season he was untagable and there is no reason why he would not continue with that form. Cotchin and Pendles for me. Redden 3rd then Stanton.

Jukes

I have all four anyway :P

hally25547


Presto

None,
My mids: Swan, GAJ, Danger, Mitchell, Ball, Embley and 4 rookies.

Jukes

Quote from: hally25547 on January 29, 2013, 03:44:12 PM
Quote from: Jukes on January 29, 2013, 03:40:23 PM
I have all four anyway :P

What is your midfield?

Cotch, Pendles, Stants, Redden, Murphy, Fyfe, then rooks.

GM

Tbh i would have Cotchy without question,but it just comes down to the salary cap,personal choice and who you rate higher.
I have a 6 mid premo strategy  starting so he will be in aftrer rd11