The Penguins

Started by Matt_352, January 24, 2013, 12:04:31 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Matt_352

Still got 21k to play with but here goes :)

DEF:  B.GODDARD  J.GRIMES  B.GIBBS  P.HANLEY  J.PITTARD  B.GOODES  J.THURLOW  D.TERLICH

MID:  D.SWAN  G.ABLETT JNR  T.COTCHIN  J.REDDEN  D.MUNDY  O.WINES  B.CROUCH  J.O'MEARA  D.TOWERS  J.VINEY

RUCK:  S.MUMFORD  M.LEUENBERGER  B.GRUNDY  D.CURRIE

FWD:  D.COX  T.ROCKLIFF  M.ROBINSON  C.RIOLI  S.MAYES  J.DANIHER  B.MACAFFER  T.LEE

Mr.Craig

I don't think Mummy and Rioli are worth it. Goldstein and Wright/Martin would be logical alternatives. You should also look at getting Staker in, probably for Goodes. The rest of your team is strong.

owenbond007

I Had mummy at the start of last year fortunately for me i got maric in for orren. kept mummy for a couple of weeks then thankfully got rid of him.

Think there is better options but at least you can trade him straight out when he doesnt play.

Rioli prob will never break out can score a big one but has more lows.

Looks like a half decent side other than that. Good one.

nrich102

Rioli  = Trap
Mummy = Fail

Other than that theres nothing to fault.

Windigo

Get rid of Mummy for the safe Goldy or H-Mac maybe.

I don't like your two fwd rookies on the field. You definitely need Staker in there somewhere.  ;)

I'd still be cautious on Hanley..

Matt_352

More of a mid pricer alternative:

Def: goddard grimes gibbs bock russell pittard goodes thurlow

Mid: swan ablettjnr cotchin dangerfield murphy wines crouch omeara viney towers

Ruck: goldstein leuenberger grundy currie

Fwd: franklin s.johnson rockliff  j.kennedy varcoe macaffer staker lee

Matt_352

Def:  goddard  gibbs  grimes  birchall  pittard  docherty  thurlow  terlich

Mid:  swan  ablettjnr  redden  murphy  fyfe  wines  crouch  omeara  viney  towers

Ruck:  sandilands  leuenberger  daw  witts

Fwd:  johnson  rockliff  robinson martin  daniher  staker  macaffer  lee