Rate My Supercoach Team

[steve_maxwell23]

Hey guys, this is my possible team for supercoach, rate it and leave any comments about what i could do better and what i've done right. When leaving a comment also post what u finished overall in supercoach last year. Team is subject to change with nab cup form and injuries. Knock yourselves out cheers!

I currently have 168,300 left with only a ruckmen to select

Backs:
S.Fisher
L.Hodge
J.Kelly
J.Macdonald
A.Mcgrath
J.Hunt
R.Ladson
emg:
B.Sheppard
A.Moore


Midfield:
G.Ablett
S.Pendlebury
B.Vince
A.Cooney
S.Burgoyne(or swap him with M.Mcveigh)
J.Trengrove
Emg:
D.Martin
J.Kayler-Thompson

Rucks:
H.Mcintosh
R.Warnock
Emg:
W.Skipper
*Ruck still to be selected

Forwards:
C.Sylvia
S.Johnson
L.Franklin
D.Giansiracusa
C.Knights(or change to P.Dangerfield)
J.Ziebell
T.Dennis-Lane
Emg:
L.Tapscott
J.Podsiadly


Any feedback would be terrific guys cheers  ;D

[jameswilson]

Back line is really bad
mids alright u could have martin on the field for burgoune then get a 94000 guy for some cash

dont know about warnock on the field and macintosh was good last year coz he was cheap. Worth a upgrade

Gia constitant 80s or 90s. Johnson isn t doin a full preseason and syilva...no deal

[yobbo21]

Don't know about the forward line..too many iffys for me and I agree the back line stinks.Bit too top heavy in the mids.go for lower options ie Armitage and Masten and get better backs

[ando_10]

7/10
backs are average but could work out agree one to many top heavy players in mids. forwards are ok accept stevie j but i really dislike your rucks.

[jameswilson]

is this your first year of sc?

[steve_maxwell23]

JamesWilson, no this is not my first year of supercoach and currently this is a temporary team like i said in my post it is subject to change due to other players forms i.e david armitage last night for the saints would be a possible replacement for burgoyne. Yes i know my backs are currently terrible, i've never been strong in this area and i don't intend to score heavily through the rucks. Who do u suggest are good money value for backline players and a player replacement for c.cylvia?

[steve_maxwell23]

Yobbo21, thanks for advice but IMO, masten is overated and will not score well in SC this, so much hype but doesn't perform well

[jameswilson]

Kennelly post looks like he will be good.

Hurley if u can afford

buchanun super value

harvey

porplezia

couldbe hawkins year


u could take a punt on waite but he isnt doing a full preseason so probably not worth it

[steve_maxwell23]

Kennelly post looks like he will be good.

Hurley if u can afford

buchanun super value

harvey

porplezia

couldbe hawkins year


u could take a punt on waite but he isnt doing a full preseason so probably not worth it

cheers mate, but if i put kenelly in, that means i would have ladson, hunt and kenelly in starting, im thinking probably to risky. Hurley won't score well enough to be a good sc player and buchanun IMO won't be consistent enough at brisbane once they have their best team on the park. harvey and the porps sound good options but i don't think hawkins will score consistently and well enough

[jameswilson]

only thig about buchanun is if they muts have picked him up 4 a reason. They wouldnt have got him for him to play in the reserves

[cozza123]

i see you have g. ablett in your team over b. sewell, overall your team blows

[ando_10]

cheers mate, but if i put kenelly in, that means i would have ladson, hunt and kenelly in starting, im thinking probably to risky. Hurley won't score well enough to be a good sc player and buchanun IMO won't be consistent enough at brisbane once they have their best team on the park. harvey and the porps sound good options but i don't think hawkins will score consistently and well enough
[/quote]
why is having kenelly risky? he was never injured just went away. so IMO no risk there. and buchanan is in there best 22 the will need him he will love being at the feet of brown and fev.

[cozza123]

ando10 you are spot on about hawkins!!!

[supercoachheroes]

Backline is crap mid is ok too heavy, 3 out of your 4 rucks are under 150 and forward line is ok, don't no why you have Dennis lane starting though.. Needs a bit of work before round 1

[steve_maxwell23]

Once again like i said guys this is only currently a temporary team and i know that i need to strengthen my backline and rucks. Any suggestions of possible players in other positions i could downgrade to upgrade players in the back or ruck or even players who are good value for their money?