The Incredible Fantastic Thread Where All Combo Questions Will Be Answered!

[Jukes]

Cox + Johnson + Mayes + Jacobs + Goodes + Fyfe
vs
NRoo + Varcoe + Siposs + Sandilands + Stanley + Embley

Cox 97, SJ 104, Mayes 68, Jacobs 93, Goodes 85, Fyfe 104
vs
Roo 95, Varcoe 75, Siposs 85, Sandi 96, Stanley 94, Embers 88

=551 vs 533
Option (a).

[Adamant]

Cox + Johnson + Mayes + Jacobs + Goodes + Fyfe
vs
NRoo + Varcoe + Siposs + Sandilands + Stanley + Embley

Cox 97, SJ 104, Mayes 68, Jacobs 93, Goodes 85, Fyfe 104
vs
Roo 95, Varcoe 75, Siposs 85, Sandi 96, Stanley 94, Embers 88

=551 vs 533
Option (a).

Brett Goodes 85?

[Jukes]

Cox + Johnson + Mayes + Jacobs + Goodes + Fyfe
vs
NRoo + Varcoe + Siposs + Sandilands + Stanley + Embley

Cox 97, SJ 104, Mayes 68, Jacobs 93, Goodes 85, Fyfe 104
vs
Roo 95, Varcoe 75, Siposs 85, Sandi 96, Stanley 94, Embers 88

=551 vs 533
Option (a).

Brett Goodes 85?

aaah I thought he meant Adam :P

Cox 97, SJ 104, Mayes 68, Jacobs 93, Goodes 65, Fyfe 104
vs
Roo 95, Varcoe 75, Siposs 85, Sandi 96, Stanley 94, Embers 88

=531 vs 533
Option (b) wins therefore now.

[Jukes]

Fyfe + Sylvia + Viney + Selwood + Moller (non-playing rook for 20k extra)
vs
K. Mitchell + Robinson + Varcoe (DPP Link) + Cotchin/Boyd (whichever you think is better) + Gorringe

cheers.

[elephants]

105 + 88 + 70 + 109 + 51

vs

75 + 98 + 77 + 116 (BOYD) + 64

423 vs 430 - second one just.



Harbrow + Macaffer vs Monfries + Docherty

[Holz]

105 + 88 + 70 + 109 + 51

vs

75 + 98 + 77 + 116 (BOYD) + 64

423 vs 430 - second one just.



Harbrow + Macaffer vs Monfries + Docherty

geez thats though Caffer and Dochers are good picks but cant work out who is worse out of Monfries and Harbrow.

really im going to have to do Caf + Spud pick v Dochers + Spud pick. I give the edge to Docherty.


Embley + SJ (assuming gets off suspensions)

v

Boyd + Any forward under 170k (not macaffer)

[elephants]

Hahah harsh on Harbrow and Monfries.

Both are capable of going 80+

Harbrow is over his injuries and has gone 88 before. Monfries at a new club and has averaged 80+ as well.. More mids time too at Port.



Boyd option I think, he has added captaincy benefits. A lot depends on the fwd under 170k though.

[Jukes]

thanks ele
@ele
Harbrow 75, Macaffer 70
vs
Gus 80, Docherty 65
=145 vs 145
DERAWWWWWW
I'd go the second option, safer.


@Holz
Embers 88, SJ 104
vs
Boyd 115, Neade 65
=192 vs 180
First option.

[elephants]

Hahaha thanks mate, FIRST DRAW!?!?!

[elephants]

Had another tinker aaand...

Docherty + any fwd (bar Cox, Rocky, Robbo, Sylvia and Siposs)

or

Byrnes + any backmen under 456k

Thanks in advance!

[Jukes]

Had another tinker aaand...

Docherty + any fwd (bar Cox, Rocky, Robbo, Sylvia and Siposs)

or

Byrnes + any backmen under 456k

Thanks in advance!

Docherty 65, SJ 104
vs
Byrnes 85, Heppell 95

=169 vs 180
Easy, Byrnes and DysHepp.

[Holz]

here is an intereting one.

Sandi + Sj (assume no suspension) + Varoce

v

Goldy + Sylvia + Broughton


esentially 2 premos + a mid pricer v  3 quasi premos

[Jukes]

here is an intereting one.

Sandi + Sj (assume no suspension) + Varoce

v

Goldy + Sylvia + Broughton


esentially 2 premos + a mid pricer v  3 quasi premos

Sandi 98, SJ 104, Varcoe 78
vs
Goldy 92, Sylvia 88, Broughton 87

=280 vs 267

[Clyde Frog]

McEvoy + Heppell + Broughton
vs
McEvoy + Duffield + Broughton
vs
Mumford + Duffield + Heppell
vs
Mumford + Duffield + Broughton

Thanks

[Jukes]

McEvoy + Heppell + Broughton
vs
McEvoy + Duffield + Broughton
vs
Mumford + Duffield + Heppell
vs
Mumford + Duffield + Broughton

90 + 96 + 87 = 273
90 + 88 + 87 = 265
90 + 88 + 96 = 274
90 + 88 + 87 = 265

I'd go with Mummy, Duffman and DysHepp.