The Incredible Fantastic Thread Where All Combo Questions Will Be Answered!

[Ricochet]

Martin + K.Stevens

v

Robbinson + Whitfield

Yeh Robbo should beat Martin by 5-8 points and Stevens v Whitfield is fairly even

[GraysFan]

Cotchin, M. Daw, M, Paparone VS K.Mitchell, Kruezer, Brynes

[Jukes]

Cotchin, M. Daw, M, Paparone VS K.Mitchell, Kruezer, Brynes

Cotch 111, Daw 55, Paparone 50?
vs
Mitchell 73, Kruuz 88, Byrnes 60

(b) wins on projected scores and JS imo, but don't go Byrnes. Go with Kieran Harper (253k); first 6 rounds will play the Boomer role while Harvey's suspended, from which Boomer has averaged 90+ numerous times in the past. Byrnes has questionable JS, role and showerhouse scoring potential.

[nickstiges]

JPK + Harper (F6)
          v
JPK + Varcoe (F6)
          v
Ablett + Any named FWD rook (F8)

[Jukes]

Ablett + Harper (F6)
          v
Ablett + Varcoe (F6)
          v
JPK + Any named FWD rook (F8)

Wait, what?
640k + 250k
640k + 230k
530k + 100k
?

[nickstiges]

Ablett + Harper (F6)
          v
Ablett + Varcoe (F6)
          v
JPK + Any named FWD rook (F8)

Wait, what?
640k + 250k
640k + 230k
530k + 100k
?

Sorry, mixed up Ablett and JPKs names there I edited it after I saw my mistake.

[Jukes]

makes sense

JPK 108, Harper 80: I believe Harper will avg 80 while he's in your side (first 6 games), JPK should average 104-106 but I've given him 2 extra because of that easy start.
vs
JPK 108, Varcoe 62
vs
Ablett 114, rook 50

JPK and Harper easily.

[Toga]

Zorko + Blicavs (R2)

Harper (F4) + Zmith

[Jukes]

Zorko + Blicavs (R2)

Harper (F4) + Zmith

Zorko 102, Blic 55
vs
Harper 80, Smith 82

Would go with (b), but GET ZORKO. He'll average more than every forward premo you have bar Rocky.

[Toga]

Zorko + Blicavs (R2)

Harper (F4) + Zmith

Zorko 102, Blic 55
vs
Harper 80, Smith 82

Would go with (b), but GET ZORKO. He'll average more than every forward premo you have bar Rocky.

Figured out I can do it using Dusty instead... Really sad to see my man leave the team but I promise, you'll be back in soon mate :'(

[Adamant]

Zorko + Blicavs (R2)

Harper (F4) + Zmith

Zorko (96) + Blicavs (65)
vs
Harper (71) + Zmith (76)

Option 1 by a country mile (and I probably underrate Zorko! :o).

[Toga]

Thanks lads... Do you think 3 guns/3 mid pricers up forward is too weak? ???

Also another one:
Beams + Harper
Hartlett + Dusty

[Jukes]

Zorko + Blicavs (R2)

Harper (F4) + Zmith

Zorko (96) + Blicavs (65)
vs
Harper (71) + Zmith (76)

Option 1 by a country mile (and I probably underrate Zorko! :o).

Didn't think two people could have such different opinions on a simple this or that :o

You're underrating Zorko massively imo. Avg 101.5 last season without his sub-affected 26 and injury-affected 69 and looks better this pre-season than he did last. Blicavs 65 can't see it happening, even if he does ruck sole for the first month is a first year ruck and rucks don't develop that quickly (see: every premo ruck). Harper will probably average 70-75, but you gotta put him up to around 80-85 because of his role for the first 6, where he'll do what Boomer does best and rack up the dt.

Thanks lads... Do you think 3 guns/3 mid pricers up forward is too weak? ???

Also another one:
Beams + Harper
Hartlett + Dusty

Beams 115, Harper 80
vs
HH 89, Dusty 90

(a) comfortably

[RookieDTer]

Robinson and Heath/Docherty and Spangher and McVeigh
v
Martin and Plowman and Spangher and McVeigh
v
Martin and Heath/DOcherty and Harper and Hartlett

Robbo 7 > Martin?
Plowman 3 > Heath/DOcherty (and which one :( ?) ?
Harper 15 > Spangher?
Mcveigh opening rounds 10 > Hartlett?

Thus, top option?

Assuming top option....
Bartel and McVeigh
v
Martin and Lids?

Thinking option b... not 100% sure about opening couple of rounds.... but, leaning towards b.

[Jukes]

Robinson and Heath/Docherty and Spangher and McVeigh
v
Martin and Plowman and Spangher and McVeigh
v
Martin and Heath/DOcherty and Harper and Hartlett

101 + 55 + 60 + 103
vs
90 + 46 + 60 + 103
vs
90 + 55 + 80 + 89

Would go with (a) yeah

Bartel and McVeigh
v
Martin and Lids?

Bartel 99 + McVeigh 104
vs
Dusty 90, Lids 113

Tie on overall predicted scoring potential, would be leaning towards (a) though. Much safer.