The Incredible Fantastic Thread Where All Combo Questions Will Be Answered!

[Adamant]

Lol now I'm torn. ::)

[Windigo]

For me it'd be an easy choice of Murphy & Martin.

[Adamant]

Yeah, I've gone with Murph and Dusty, but just downgraded Wines to Viney and upgraded D-Mart to Buddy.

[Windigo]

Hm, an interesting choice.

[Toga]

Heppell + M.Murphy + Patton + Neade

Stevenson + Ablett + Karnezis + Knights

[Windigo]

Heppell + M.Murphy + Patton + Neade

Stevenson + Ablett + Karnezis + Knights

Stevo is better than Neade. GAJ is better than Murphy. Karnesis on form is better than Patton, yet Heppell is better than Knights. But not drastically.  ;)

[Adamant]

Heppell + M.Murphy + Patton + Neade

Stevenson + Ablett + Karnezis + Knights

Stevo is better than Neade. GAJ is better than Murphy. Karnesis on form is better than Patton, yet Heppell is better than Knights. But not drastically.  ;)

Yeah, agree with this. Although I reckon Patton is about par with Karnesis. Karnesis is getting overhyped IMO. Let's face it, he's the current fad pick, just like Siposs, Tambling, etc.

[Toga]

Heppell + M.Murphy + Patton + Neade

Stevenson + Ablett + Karnezis + Knights

Stevo is better than Neade. GAJ is better than Murphy. Karnesis on form is better than Patton, yet Heppell is better than Knights. But not drastically.  ;)

Only problem is my backline is now: Goddard, Gibbs, Hartlett, Goodes, Pittard, Stevenson (Docherty, Terlich)

A bit weak? ???


Another options is to go through with the Option 2, but then go Ablett -> Boyd, Wines -> Lonergan and Knights -> Neade... Worth it or should I leave it? :-X

[Jukes]

Heppell + M.Murphy + Patton + Neade

Stevenson + Ablett + Karnezis + Knights

Dys 96, Murph 106, Patton 73, Neade 55
vs
Lewey 68, Ablett 114, Karny 75, Knights 70

=330 vs 327

Two keepers too vs one.

[Windigo]

I was never keen on Sippos. Was luke warm on Tambling.

But Karnezis destroyed the NEAFL.  :P

Only problem is my backline is now: Goddard, Gibbs, Hartlett, Goodes, Pittard, Stevenson (Docherty, Terlich)

It just means your strong elsewhere.  :)

[Adamant]

I was never keen on Sippos. Was luke warm on Tambling.

But Karnezis destroyed the NEAFL.  :P

Only problem is my backline is now: Goddard, Gibbs, Hartlett, Goodes, Pittard, Stevenson (Docherty, Terlich)

It just means your strong elsewhere.  :)

Fair enough, but I didn't hear anyone mention Karnezis before his latest NAB game. I just think people are getting too carried away based on a strong NAB performance.

[Windigo]

Yeah well. I think we're getting carried away in a controlled manner. Harry Taylor destroyed a game. But no one's locking him in.  :P

If we did digging on Karny and found that he averaged 10 possies & averaged like 60 in the NEAFL we'd just think that it's an abnormality or a blue moon event that he scored so well.

But averaging 26 touches, going 30+ 7 times and booting 3+ goals on multiple occasions does bring interest to him.  :P

[Adamant]

Yeah, ok. Fair enough mate.

I'd really like to see you stick with him though, pending next weeks NAB. I know you stuck to your gut with Golby last year and was tempted by Ellis/Gray, but with 44 trades this year, why not? ;)

[Windigo]

Yes.... Probably not my finest achievement. Was on Brad Symes the year before that as well. Not a good track record.  ::)

[essendon2]

Yeah, ok. Fair enough mate.

I'd really like to see you stick with him though, pending next weeks NAB. I know you stuck to your gut with Golby last year and was tempted by Ellis/Gray, but with 44 trades this year, why not? ;)

I'm sticking with Karnezis, he's been in my team since before NAB Cup began haha
he's certainly more locked than Varcoe atm too  :P