The Incredible Fantastic Thread Where All Combo Questions Will Be Answered!

[essendon2]

Cloke, Sylvia or Bruest?

[Windigo]

Colin.  8)

[Jukes]

Cloke, Sylvia or Bruest?

My main man Trav Cloke

[Adamant]

Cloke, Sylvia or Bruest?

My main man Trav Cloke

Sylvia easily. He's had 3 years of 90+ averages. Cloke has only had one and Bruest's highest is 76.

[Artax]

Can't go past Colin there.

I got him pretty late in an elite draft & still got laughed at

[Jukes]

Cloke, Sylvia or Bruest?

My main man Trav Cloke

Sylvia easily. He's had 3 years of 90+ averages. Cloke has only had one and Bruest's highest is 76.

Games played in each season since debut,
Cloke: 15, 15, 22, 21, 19, 20, 22, 22
Sylvia: 3, 16, 15, 16, 18, 17, 15, 19, 17
Trav has been in the system a year less but has played almost 40 more games...

Even if Sylvia averages 93 and Cloke 83, Cloke will still overall score more because he'll play 21-22 games while Sylvia will play 15-18

My predictions
Sylvia: 90 average, 16 games
Cloke: 94 average, 21 games

[Adamant]

Cloke, Sylvia or Bruest?

My main man Trav Cloke

Sylvia easily. He's had 3 years of 90+ averages. Cloke has only had one and Bruest's highest is 76.

Games played in each season since debut,
Cloke: 15, 15, 22, 21, 19, 20, 22, 22
Sylvia: 3, 16, 15, 16, 18, 17, 15, 19, 17
Trav has been in the system a year less but has played almost 40 more games...

Even if Sylvia averages 93 and Cloke 83, Cloke will still overall score more because he'll play 21-22 games while Sylvia will play 15-18

My predictions
Sylvia: 90 average, 16 games
Cloke: 94 average, 21 games

Yeah, good point, but we just use one of our many trades to trade him when he goes down.

[Jukes]

Cloke, Sylvia or Bruest?

My main man Trav Cloke

Sylvia easily. He's had 3 years of 90+ averages. Cloke has only had one and Bruest's highest is 76.

Games played in each season since debut,
Cloke: 15, 15, 22, 21, 19, 20, 22, 22
Sylvia: 3, 16, 15, 16, 18, 17, 15, 19, 17
Trav has been in the system a year less but has played almost 40 more games...

Even if Sylvia averages 93 and Cloke 83, Cloke will still overall score more because he'll play 21-22 games while Sylvia will play 15-18

My predictions
Sylvia: 90 average, 16 games
Cloke: 94 average, 21 games

Yeah, good point, but we just use one of our many trades to trade him when he goes down.

The thing is, he'll miss a week a month almost. He never goes down with LTIs, just 1 week things that sometimes strecth to 3, ie stupid things like a blood clot in his toe.

Good bloke, but not as good of a bloke as Trav. Same applies for their dt skills for 2013. 

[Adamant]

Cloke, Sylvia or Bruest?

My main man Trav Cloke

Sylvia easily. He's had 3 years of 90+ averages. Cloke has only had one and Bruest's highest is 76.

Games played in each season since debut,
Cloke: 15, 15, 22, 21, 19, 20, 22, 22
Sylvia: 3, 16, 15, 16, 18, 17, 15, 19, 17
Trav has been in the system a year less but has played almost 40 more games...

Even if Sylvia averages 93 and Cloke 83, Cloke will still overall score more because he'll play 21-22 games while Sylvia will play 15-18

My predictions
Sylvia: 90 average, 16 games
Cloke: 94 average, 21 games

Yeah, good point, but we just use one of our many trades to trade him when he goes down.

The thing is, he'll miss a week a month almost. He never goes down with LTIs, just 1 week things that sometimes strecth to 3, ie stupid things like a blood clot in his toe.

Good bloke, but not as good of a bloke as Trav. Same applies for their dt skills for 2013.

Haha that made me laugh. I remember that.

At least with Sylvia we know that he just needs to start the year fit and he'll average 90+. Cloke had a major form issues last year and can he get back to his 2011 standard? I think he'll go 85+ pretty easily, but still not completely sold.

[Jukes]

Last season Cloke had two major factors that prohibited his high-scoring ability;
>ongoing contract discussions and disputes
>getting double teamed every week because he was Collingwood's only good forward

He has solved these issues in preparation for 2013 by,
>signing a new contract
>getting in Lynch, the return of Krakouer and Macaffer, some presence by Grundy/Witts up forward

Should go back to 90+ easily, could improve on his 2011 average of 95.

[essendon2]

Fyfe + Hartlett/Duffield + Wright/Martin
vs
Ball + Stanley/Grimes + Robinson/Zorko

[Jukes]

Fyfe + Hartlett/Duffield + Wright/Martin
vs
Ball + Stanley/Grimes + Robinson/Zorko

Fyfe 105, HH/Duffman 88, Wright 92
vs
Ball 87, Grimes 95, Zorko 103

=285 vs 285
WOW
I'd go with option (b) however. Grimes and Zorko are keepers while can only see Wright being a keeper in option (a).

[Holz]

Cloke, Sylvia or Bruest?

watts :)

[essendon2]

Cloke, Sylvia or Bruest?

watts :)

legit?

is he in your team then?  :P

[RookieDTer]

Interesting one for ya....
Beams (VC) (M2), Fyfe (M4) and B.Goodes (D7 at the moment) - if he is named, would probably move Terlich to D7 and put B.Goodes in at D6.
v
Pendles (VC) (M2), Scott Selwood (M4) and L. Stevenson (D7)

I am leaning towards the first one - esp. given that gives me a better VC... But, I don't see too many DTers pick up Beams. Am I missing something? Why am I the only one picking Beams?

My M1 is Ablett.