The Incredible Fantastic Thread Where All Combo Questions Will Be Answered!

Started by Adamant, January 08, 2013, 10:58:42 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Windigo

Really depends if Berger plays....

I'd rather him to Goldy. Docherty looks like a slow burner, so I'd rather Vlastuin. Mundy over Wines & GAJ over Cotch.

So that's 2-2. Tough choice, can't go past GAJ in any combo situation for mine.  :-\

Jukes

Quote from: Holzman on March 14, 2013, 02:05:07 PM
Goldy + Vlaustin + Wines + Ablett

v

Burger + Docherty + Mundy + Cotchin

Goldy 85, Vlas 70, Wines 80, Spudlett 115
vs
Berger 80, Docherty 60, Mundy 100, Cotch 111.

Toga

Hartlett vs Fyfe?

Have slid Hartlett into my M5 for the moment for lack of cash, but have 50K left over. I daresay Fyfey will outscore Hartlett (pretty comfortably) but HH has a dream start & gives me DPP flexibility (to swap with Vlastuin: D4).

Ricochet

Quote from: Toga on March 14, 2013, 07:12:02 PM
Hartlett vs Fyfe?

Have slid Hartlett into my M5 for the moment for lack of cash, but have 50K left over. I daresay Fyfey will outscore Hartlett (pretty comfortably) but HH has a dream start & gives me DPP flexibility (to swap with Vlastuin: D4).
I still think you need to go with Fyfe, he could average 10-15 more points that HH

Toga


Toga

Another quick one - is Jasper Pittard a must-have?

If i did Pittard -> Terlich I would be able to afford Zorko -> Maric...

RookieDTer

Quote from: Toga on March 14, 2013, 07:24:13 PM
Another quick one - is Jasper Pittard a must-have?

If i did Pittard -> Terlich I would be able to afford Zorko -> Maric...
Nah. I went - Pittard about 10 days ago.

shower NAB cup for DT points + a rookie = unlikely to be in my team.

Though, to be fair, I went +Vlaustin.

GM

Quote from: Toga on March 14, 2013, 07:24:13 PM
Another quick one - is Jasper Pittard a must-have?

If i did Pittard -> Terlich I would be able to afford Zorko -> Maric...
From Nab form mate Terlich will score better.

Toga


blues boy

Fyfe(M5) + Z. Smith(R2) + J. Bartel (R2) Cash Left = $33,000

or

Deledio(M4) + M. Leuenberger (R2) + J.Roughead(F4) Cash Left = 10,000

Which one and why?

RookieDTer

Quote from: blues boy on March 14, 2013, 09:06:22 PM
Fyfe(M5) + Z. Smith(R2) + J. Bartel (R2) Cash Left = $33,000

or

Deledio(M4) + M. Leuenberger (R2) + J.Roughead(F4) Cash Left = 10,000

Which one and why?
Delidio 10 points > Fyfe
Burger not a good choice.
Roughead probably about as good as Bartel - maybe 2-5 points less?

Could even do Roughead to R2, -Burger + Karnezis/Varcoe/Byrnes/Knights to F2.... then get Burger back in a few rounds in if you want (putting Roughead back to Fwd line)

Jukes

Quote from: blues boy on March 14, 2013, 09:06:22 PM
Fyfe(M5) + Z. Smith(R2) + J. Bartel (R2) Cash Left = $33,000

or

Deledio(M4) + M. Leuenberger (R2) + J.Roughead(F4) Cash Left = 10,000

Which one and why?

Fyfe 101, Smith 80, Bartel 95
vs
Lids 112, Leuey 80, Roughead 96

blues boy

Quote from: RookieDTer on March 14, 2013, 09:13:00 PM
Quote from: blues boy on March 14, 2013, 09:06:22 PM
Fyfe(M5) + Z. Smith(R2) + J. Bartel (R2) Cash Left = $33,000

or

Deledio(M4) + M. Leuenberger (R2) + J.Roughead(F4) Cash Left = 10,000

Which one and why?
Delidio 10 points > Fyfe
Burger not a good choice.
Roughead probably about as good as Bartel - maybe 2-5 points less?

Could even do Roughead to R2, -Burger + Karnezis/Varcoe/Byrnes/Knights to F2.... then get Burger back in a few rounds in if you want (putting Roughead back to Fwd line)

Already have varcoe and karnezis in at F5 and F6 so dont think i should get another one!

I can put burger on the bench and sub roughead into rucks and then bring Macaffer onto the field?

RookieDTer

Quote from: blues boy on March 14, 2013, 09:17:12 PM
Quote from: RookieDTer on March 14, 2013, 09:13:00 PM
Quote from: blues boy on March 14, 2013, 09:06:22 PM
Fyfe(M5) + Z. Smith(R2) + J. Bartel (R2) Cash Left = $33,000

or

Deledio(M4) + M. Leuenberger (R2) + J.Roughead(F4) Cash Left = 10,000

Which one and why?
Delidio 10 points > Fyfe
Burger not a good choice.
Roughead probably about as good as Bartel - maybe 2-5 points less?

Could even do Roughead to R2, -Burger + Karnezis/Varcoe/Byrnes/Knights to F2.... then get Burger back in a few rounds in if you want (putting Roughead back to Fwd line)

Already have varcoe and karnezis in at F5 and F6 so dont think i should get another one!

I can put burger on the bench and sub roughead into rucks and then bring Macaffer onto the field?
Yea,. I considered that strongly.

I went with Currie at R2... but I know that is not for everyone!

blues boy

Quote from: RookieDTer on March 14, 2013, 09:20:32 PM
Quote from: blues boy on March 14, 2013, 09:17:12 PM
Quote from: RookieDTer on March 14, 2013, 09:13:00 PM
Quote from: blues boy on March 14, 2013, 09:06:22 PM
Fyfe(M5) + Z. Smith(R2) + J. Bartel (R2) Cash Left = $33,000

or

Deledio(M4) + M. Leuenberger (R2) + J.Roughead(F4) Cash Left = 10,000

Which one and why?
Delidio 10 points > Fyfe
Burger not a good choice.
Roughead probably about as good as Bartel - maybe 2-5 points less?

Could even do Roughead to R2, -Burger + Karnezis/Varcoe/Byrnes/Knights to F2.... then get Burger back in a few rounds in if you want (putting Roughead back to Fwd line)

Already have varcoe and karnezis in at F5 and F6 so dont think i should get another one!

I can put burger on the bench and sub roughead into rucks and then bring Macaffer onto the field?
Yea,. I considered that strongly.

I went with Currie at R2... but I know that is not for everyone!

Could do this
Deledio -----> Moloney
Leuenberger -----> Goldy or any ruck besides Cox (F1) or Big Ivan (cant afford him)