This or That ? Cotchin vs Boyd

[GM]

 

Anyone who is putting Boyd in their team next year might as well not enter... lol, bit harsh, but it's the truth.

:oWhy?

[JBs-Hawks]

Anyone who is putting Boyd in their team next year might as well not enter... lol, bit harsh, but it's the truth.

I bet there will plenty of teams with Boyd that will out rank you ;)

[Justin Bieber]

Well I said from the start.

[JBs-Hawks]

Yea and there will be plenty who start with him that will beat you too ;) can't beat a consistent proven performer.

[Football Factory]

Anyone who is putting Boyd in their team next year might as well not enter... lol, bit harsh, but it's the truth.

I wasnt quite sure if you were brain dead .. but that confirms it

[SydneyRox]

Anyone who is putting Boyd in their team next year might as well not enter... lol, bit harsh, but it's the truth.

I wasnt quite sure if you were brain dead .. but that confirms it

Considering some of his comments in other posts I am surprised you took so long  :o

[Football Factory]

Anyone who is putting Boyd in their team next year might as well not enter... lol, bit harsh, but it's the truth.

I wasnt quite sure if you were brain dead .. but that confirms it

Considering some of his comments in other posts I am surprised you took so long  :o

Yeah true ..   :-[

[tbagrocks]

I'm not starting Boyd, upgraded last year and will probably have to again, if he averages the same he will drop in value while the Murphy's and Fyfe's etc will rise, so if Boyd is still going better then with 30 trades you can afford to swap, this will be my strategy

[Justin Bieber]

Well FF, Sydney Rox and other smart arses. Is Boyd in your STARTING team atm?

If yes then well I look silly, but if that is a yes then lol @ you.

[Football Factory]

I'm not starting Boyd, upgraded last year and will probably have to again, if he averages the same he will drop in value while the Murphy's and Fyfe's etc will rise, so if Boyd is still going better then with 30 trades you can afford to swap, this will be my strategy

I wont argue with your strategy .. more than one way to skin a cat ..Im going to stick with, start the best and upgrade to the rest, has served me well over the years. I needed an extra 6 trades last year i was short early so i wont be relying on these trades to make sideways trades etc.

[Football Factory]

Well FF, Sydney Rox and other smart arses. Is Boyd in your STARTING team atm?

If yes then well I look silly, but if that is a yes then lol @ you.

He's been in my starting line-up for the last 3 years. How would starting with one of the best mean that you might aswell not enter your team next year ..

[Capper]

Well its not only Boyd's age that worries me but the dogs are the biggest worry for me. He got alot of points last year of a quick one-two HB and then a kick, but that kick sometimes went to the opposition. The dogs were shot last year, will be interesting to see how they go this year.

Cotching for me, price, age all on his side

[Toga]

Both ripper players but I will be starting with Cotchin or Murph and looking to upgrade to Boyd if he keeps up last season's form.

Like people have said, age, price, and natural development on Cotch & Murphy's side.

[Football Factory]

Alot of good arguements for Cotchin still undecided its a hard choice for me .. still a long time to go. Thanks for feedback

[Grazz]

I'm not starting Boyd, upgraded last year and will probably have to again, if he averages the same he will drop in value while the Murphy's and Fyfe's etc will rise, so if Boyd is still going better then with 30 trades you can afford to swap, this will be my strategy

I wont argue with your strategy .. more than one way to skin a cat ..Im going to stick with, start the best and upgrade to the rest, has served me well over the years. I needed an extra 6 trades last year i was short early so i wont be relying on these trades to make sideways trades etc.

+1 If it aint broke dont try to fix it.  ;)