MTTY's Team Rater Thread

[MTTY]

Post your teams in this thread and I will give them a fairly in depth rating and feedback

[kilbluff1985]

me first me first lol

TEAM NAME: FIGJAM
DEF: B. Goddard, B. Gibbs, D. Heppell, G. Broughton, J. Pittard, D. Terlich (B. Goodes, L. Osborne)
MID: G. Ablett jnr, S. Pendlebury, K. Jack, L. Shuey, N. Fyfe, O. Wines, B. Crouch, J. O'Meara (L. Hunter, J. Viney)
RUC: T. Goldstein, M. Leuenberger (M. Daw, S. Rowe)
FWD: T. Rockliff, S. Johnson, J. Lewis, D. Martin, A. Christensen, B. Staker (T. Lee, B. Kennedy)
CASH LEFT: $41,500


some guys not locked in like Heppell, Jack, Fyfe, Johnson, Martin, Christensen they are just in todays team lol

[Nige]

NamesAreOverrated Fanplanner squad in the Super Coach competition coached by Nigey95. Salary cap left: $106,200.

Brendon Goddard, Bryce Gibbs, Grant Birchall, Tom Clurey, Greg Broughton, Brett Goodes
Brent Staker, Dean Terlich

Gary Ablett jnr, Scott Pendlebury, Trent Cotchin, Marc Murphy, Matt Priddis, Kane Mitchell, Oliver Wines, Brad Crouch
Jaeger O'Meara, Jack Viney

Todd Goldstein, Matthew Leuenberger
Daniel Currie, Brodie Grundy

Lance Franklin, Dean Cox, Tom Rockliff, Troy Menzel, Jake Stringer, Travis Varcoe
Taylor Garner, Brent Macaffer


Posted this on a few threads now, but each person has a different opinion and can't go wrong with a bit of feedback. Wouldn't mind another opinion, cheers MTTY. I'm fairly happy with it, but would love your thoughts.

[MTTY]

me first me first lol

TEAM NAME: FIGJAM
DEF: B. Goddard, B. Gibbs, D. Heppell, G. Broughton, J. Pittard, D. Terlich (B. Goodes, L. Osborne)
MID: G. Ablett jnr, S. Pendlebury, K. Jack, L. Shuey, N. Fyfe, O. Wines, B. Crouch, J. O'Meara (L. Hunter, J. Viney)
RUC: T. Goldstein, M. Leuenberger (M. Daw, S. Rowe)
FWD: T. Rockliff, S. Johnson, J. Lewis, D. Martin, A. Christensen, B. Staker (T. Lee, B. Kennedy)
CASH LEFT: $41,500
some guys not locked in like Heppell, Jack, Fyfe, Johnson, Martin, Christensen they are just in todays team lol

Backs:

- Goddard, Gibbs, Heppell and Broughton are all capable to push into the top 6 averaging backs, with Heppell the least likely in my opinion.

- Heppell and Broughton are very good UVP's (Under Valued Player)

- Your structure for defence is one of my favour ones (which are 4/1/3 or 4/0/4)

- Pittard, Goodes and Osbourne should all push for selection

- Terlich a fairly good rookie, although he will be competing for spots with Garland, Strauss and Nicholson

- Very good use of having a DPP rookie

- No (in my opinion) Inbetweeners

Rating: 9.75

Midfield:

- Ablett and Pendlebury both capable of being in the top 8 averaging midfielders

- Jack & Shuey for me are Inbetweeners, in that they won't be in the top 8 averaging mids and won't generate enough cash. Shuey to a lesser extent as he may generate a bit more cash, but still can't see him in the top 8 averaging mids

- Fyfe a very good UVP in my opinion

- Not one of my favoured structures for midfield but i do see the appeal to start strong in there

- All of your rookies will be in contention for round 1

- Hunter a good unique rookie, that can score well

- Lack of a rookie C/F and B/C is not good in my opinion of a starting team

Rating: 8/10


Rucks:

- Leuenberger should generate a ton of cash, so is a very good UVP

- Goldstein also a good UVP who is cheap and could push for a top 2 averaging ruck spot

- R/F link in Rowe

- Daw a good option especially with him probably being the first back up to Goldstein

Rating: 10/10


Forwards:

- Rockliff and Johnson very capable of being in the top 6 averaging forwards

- Personal opinion is that i don't like Lewis as i see him as an Inbetweener (won't be in top 6 averaging forwards and is not a UVP)

- Another personal preference is not to have Martin, however he is a UVP so i won't talk you into or out of selecting him

- Allen Christensen a fairly good UVP to pick

- Staker, Lee and Kennedy all good choice, Kennedy to a lesser extent as he may not fit into the Pies 22

- A rookie C/F link is good in Kennedy

- Personally not a fan of the structure

Rating: 9.25


Final Rating: 37/40

[kilbluff1985]

Thanks mate but i think Jack is a good option has a pretty easy draw in the 1st half of the season and does well vs weaker teams was out of him or JPK but Jack does better vs weaker teams

[MTTY]

NamesAreOverrated Fanplanner squad in the Super Coach competition coached by Nigey95. Salary cap left: $106,200.

Brendon Goddard, Bryce Gibbs, Grant Birchall, Tom Clurey, Greg Broughton, Brett Goodes
Brent Staker, Dean Terlich

Gary Ablett jnr, Scott Pendlebury, Trent Cotchin, Marc Murphy, Matt Priddis, Kane Mitchell, Oliver Wines, Brad Crouch
Jaeger O'Meara, Jack Viney

Todd Goldstein, Matthew Leuenberger
Daniel Currie, Brodie Grundy

Lance Franklin, Dean Cox, Tom Rockliff, Troy Menzel, Jake Stringer, Travis Varcoe
Taylor Garner, Brent Macaffer


Posted this on a few threads now, but each person has a different opinion and can't go wrong with a bit of feedback. Wouldn't mind another opinion, cheers MTTY. I'm fairly happy with it, but would love your thoughts.

Backs:

- Goddard, Gibbs, Birchall and Broughton all possible top 6 averaging defenders

- Goodes, Staker, Terlich all good rookie options, however Terlich will be fighting for spots with the likes of Garland, Nicholson and Strauss

- Clurey for me will lack JS, if selected round 1 though could be a good unique

- One of my preferred backline structures

- Broughton is a very good UVP (Under Valued Player) options

- Goodes a good C/B rookie

Rating: 9.5/10

Midfield:

- Ablett, Pendlebury, Cotchin and Murphy all capable of being top 8 averaging mids

- Murphy a good UVP option

- Priddis is an Inbetween player for me, in that he will not be in the top 8 averaging mids and will not generate enough cash

- All good rookies who are pushing for round 1 selection

- Not one of my preferred midfield structures but i see the appeal in starting strong in the midfield

- Lack of C/F and B/C rookies are problem for me

Rating: 8.5/10

Rucks:

- Goldstein a good UVP that will push for top 2 averaging rucks and earn you cash

- Leuenberger another good UVP that will generate cash

- Grundy is a good rookie option as he will push for selection, with Currie also a good option as i gather one of Daw or Currie will back up Goldstein if injured

- No R/F rookie, isn't too much of a problem however

Rating: 10/10

Forwards:

- Franklin over priced for me, but with the amount of people jumping off could be a bit of a unique

- Cox, Rockliff and Franklin all capable of being in the top 6 averaging forwards

- Varcoe a very good UVP, who also offers DPP

- C/F rookie in Menzel is very good

- Macaffer, Menzel and Stringer all good rookie options

- I think Garner will struggle for games, thus there are better rookie options

- Not a fan of the structure

Rating: 8.75/10


Final Rating: 36.75/40

[MTTY]

Thanks mate but i think Jack is a good option has a pretty easy draw in the 1st half of the season and does well vs weaker teams was out of him or JPK but Jack does better vs weaker teams

Fair opinion and a good one. Going off my rules for creating a starting team, I will not be taking any players that drop into his category. Could come off though, so could be a great pick after all and force others into using a trade to bring him in.  :)

[FisherSaints]

Brendon Goddard, Greg Broughton, Grant Birchall, Paul Duffield, Leigh Osborne, Brent Staker
Nick Vlastuin, Sam Colquhoun

Gary Ablett jnr, Dane Swan, Bryce Gibbs, David Mundy, Luke Ball, Trent Cotchin, Jaeger O'Meara, Anthony Morabito
Jack Viney, Brett Goodes

Todd Goldstein, Matthew Leuenberger
Max Gawn, Brodie Grundy

Tom Rockliff, Lance Franklin, Nathan Bock, Matthew de Boer, Mark LeCras, Jake Stringer
Rory Atkins, Cadeyn Williams


Salary cap left: $11,200.

Need to work on my forward bench just put them in so that I could post it up now

[MTTY]

Brendon Goddard, Greg Broughton, Grant Birchall, Paul Duffield, Leigh Osborne, Brent Staker
Nick Vlastuin, Sam Colquhoun

Gary Ablett jnr, Dane Swan, Bryce Gibbs, David Mundy, Luke Ball, Trent Cotchin, Jaeger O'Meara, Anthony Morabito
Jack Viney, Brett Goodes

Todd Goldstein, Matthew Leuenberger
Max Gawn, Brodie Grundy

Tom Rockliff, Lance Franklin, Nathan Bock, Matthew de Boer, Mark LeCras, Jake Stringer
Rory Atkins, Cadeyn Williams


Salary cap left: $11,200.

Need to work on my forward bench just put them in so that I could post it up now

Backs:

- Goddard, Broughton, Birchall and Duffield all possible top 6 averaging defenders

- Broughton a very good UVP (Under Valued Player)

- Osbourne, Staker, Vlastuin and Colquhoun should all be in contention for round 1

- You have a B/C rookie which is good (You have two)

- One of my preferred structures for defence

Rating: 10/10

Midfield:

- Abett, Swan, Mundy and Cotchin all capable of being top 8 averaging mids

- Mundy a very good UVP

- Ball also a very good UVP

- Big no for me with Gibbs, play him in defence if you pick him

- You have a rookie B/C but no C/F rookie

- All good rookie selections

- Not one of my preferred structures but i see the appeal in starting strong in the mids

Rating: 9/10

Rucks:

- Goldstein a very good UVP, could be a top 2 averaging ruck and will generate cash

- Leuenberger another good UVP as he will generate a lot of cash

- Love the pick of Gawn, he could overtake Jamar at some stage this season

- Grundy will push for selection this season

- Lack of a R/F isn't overly worrying

Rating: 10/10

Forwards:

- Rockliff and Franklin both capable of being top 6 averaging forwards

- de Boer, Bock and LeCras all good UVP options

- Franklin too over priced for me, but could be a fairly unique pick with the amount of people jumping off him

- Not a fan of this structure

- Stringer a very good rookie choice

- (I know you said that these rookies are really just place holders, so i wont take them into consideration for the time being)

Rating: 9/10


Final Rating: 38/40

[kilbluff1985]

so what forward structure do you like mate just curious

[MTTY]

so what forward structure do you like mate just curious

My preference's are:

4/1/3

OR

5/0/3

OR

4/0/4

[Obese Arachnid]

Would love a rate if you have time thanks.

TEAM NAME: Krakouer Hymen

Defenders:

Bryce Gibbs [MID], Paul Duffield,Hamish Hartlett [MID], Greg Broughton [FWD], Cameron Pedersen [RUC], Jasper Pittard
N Wright Dean Terlich

Midfielders:

Gary Ablett, Scott Pendlebury, Marc Murphy, David Mundy, Nathan Hrovat, Ben Kennedy[FWD], Jaeger O'Meara, Jack Viney
Brett Goodes [DEF], Brad Crouch

Rucks:

Todd Goldstein, Matthew Leuenberger,
Dan Currie, Liam McBean [FWD]


Forwards
Lance Franklin, Nic Naitanui [RUC], Dean Cox [RUC], Tom Rockliff [MID], Dale Thomas [MID], Brent Staker [DEF]
Brent Macaffer, Tom Lee

Cash Left: $0

[kilbluff1985]

so what forward structure do you like mate just curious

My preference's are:

4/1/3

OR

5/0/3

OR

4/0/4

what do you class my one as thought it was pretty close to 4/1/3 Martin is a premium if you ask me

[MTTY]

Would love a rate if you have time thanks.

TEAM NAME: Krakouer Hymen

Defenders:

Bryce Gibbs [MID], Paul Duffield,Hamish Hartlett [MID], Greg Broughton [FWD], Cameron Pedersen [RUC], Jasper Pittard
N Wright Dean Terlich

Midfielders:

Gary Ablett, Scott Pendlebury, Marc Murphy, David Mundy, Nathan Hrovat, Ben Kennedy[FWD], Jaeger O'Meara, Jack Viney
Brett Goodes [DEF], Brad Crouch

Rucks:

Todd Goldstein, Matthew Leuenberger,
Dan Currie, Liam McBean [FWD]


Forwards
Lance Franklin, Nic Naitanui [RUC], Dean Cox [RUC], Tom Rockliff [MID], Dale Thomas [MID], Brent Staker [DEF]
Brent Macaffer, Tom Lee

Cash Left: $0

Backs:

- Gibbs, Duffield, Hartlett and Broughton all possible top 6 averaging defenders

- Broughton a good UVP (Under Valued Player), and so is Pedersen

- Pittard, Wright and Terlich will all be in contention come round 1, Terlich a little less as he must compete with Nicholson, Garland and Strauss. Especially like the pick of Wright

- Good structure and is my preferred one

Rating: 9.75/10

Midfield:

- Ablett, Pendlebury, Murphy and Mundy all capable of being in the top 8 averaging mids

- Mundy a very good UVP

- All rookie will be in contention come round 1

- You have a C/F and C/B rookie which is very good

- Like the pick of Hrovat especially as if he gets games, i think he could be similar to Toby Greene

- Like the structure as its one of my preferred ones

Rating: 10/10

Rucks:

- Goldstein is a great UVP, will generate cash and is a good chance to be in the top 2 averaging rucks

- Leuenberger a good UVP pick and will generate cash

- A R/F, which is good to see, although my personal preference is Rowe

- Dan Currie a good pick as he or Daw should back up Goldstein if he is injured

Rating: 10/10

Forwards:

- Franklin too over priced for me, however with the amount of people jumping off he could be fairly unique

- Naitanui and Thomas currently recovering from injuries but should be fine

- Franklin, Rockliff, Cox, Naitanui and Thomas are all pushing for top 6 averaging forwards in my opinion

- Staker, Macaffer and Lee all good rookie picks

- Would prefer to see a C/F rookie here too

- Could be a little overstocked up forward, but it seems you have spent your money well and it does not hinder your other areas

Rating: 9.5/10


Final Rating: 39.25/40

[MTTY]

so what forward structure do you like mate just curious

My preference's are:

4/1/3

OR

5/0/3

OR

4/0/4

what do you class my one as thought it was pretty close to 4/1/3 Martin is a premium if you ask me

Close but i don't view Martin as a premium